Alternatives to Criminal Court
In court:
1.) Guilty Plea
2.) Plea negotiation
Alternative Measures Outside of Criminal Court
1.) Community service
2.) Apology
3.) Restorative justice
Restorative Justice
Victim-offender reconciliation. Where the offender goes through a fault-admitting program
1.) Offender gets to hear how their actions impacted them
2.) The victims get to hear why they did it
Civil Matters
Dispute resolution between:
1.) Individuals
2.) Corporations
3.) State and the individual
(e.g., divorces, mergers, high bill increases)
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Resolving disputes without court
5 Types of Alternative Dispute Resolution
1.) Negotiation
2.) Mediation
3.) Arbitration
4.) Med-arb
5.) Collaborative law
Negotiation
2+ parties meet with or without lawyers in an attempt to come to an agreement
Mediation
Lawyers or professional negotiators help to reach an outcome in a negotiation
Arbitration
The person in the negotiation that makes the final decision
Collaborative Law
Focuses on finding the best resolution for both parties. Accomplished by both sides hiring lawyers but choosing not to go to court
Med-Arb
A mediator who hears the negotiation, if the parties cannot decide, the med-arb will choose the outcome
How to Negotiate
Interest-based negotiations:
1.) Identify your interest
2.) Identify other sides’ interests
3.) Evaluate the best and worst outcomes
4.) Do not give up too easily
Family Law
Deals with domestic partnerships, separation, and divorce
Family Law Issues
Parenting schedules, spousal/child support, and property division
Jurisdiction of Family Law
s. 91: Divorce and marriage = Federal
s. 92: Ceremony, property, and civil rights = Provincial
Grounds for Divorce
s. 8: Separated for 1+ years, proved adultery, and abuse
Issues with Grounds for Divorce
Expensive and hard to prove, adultery and abuse through court (most wait the year)
Guardianship
Responsibility and decision-making for the child
Parenting Time
Time spent with the child
Best Interest of the Child
Looks at:
1.) Health
2.) Emotional well-being
3.) Nature of the relationship
4.) History of care
5.) Ability of potential guardian
Child Support
Federal child support guidelines: Kids should have a similar quality of life in both parents’ homes (the wealthier parent pays more to offset the differences)
Spousal Support
Purpose is to support the self-sufficiency of each spouse within a reasonable period of time
Property Division
Everything that isn’t a human being or owned before the marriage is to be divided among the spouses
Jurisdictions for Family Law Disputes
Child support = Provincial
Property division and spousal support = Supreme Court