features of adjudication that make it central
orthodox theory of adjudication
what judges do is reasonably predictable because judges are relatively constrained by the law
heretical theory of adjudication
judicial decision-taking is reasonably predictable in spite of being relatively constrained by the law
common law theory
the job of adjudication is to apply the common consensus of the community
formalism
a clear system of rules
scepticism
judicial decisions mostly predictable but not determined by paper rules