What is the Clever Hans effect?
-Unintentional influence of a questioner or observer’s subtle, non-verbal cues on a subject’s behavior, leading the subject to produce a desired response that doesn’t stem from genuine understanding or ability
-Animal senses what someone wants them to do even if the human is not deliberately giving them signals
What does the clever hans effect say about animal perception and learning?
-Reveals that animals, particularly in human-animal interactions, are highly adept at perceiving and reacting to subtle, unconscious human cues, rather than possessing advanced cognitive abilities
-Animals can be very perceptive and can learn by being attentive
What are some ways to mitigate the clever hans effect in studies of animal behavior?
Design experiments using blinded protocols where observers don’t know the hypothesis or desired outcome
What is Lloyd Morgan’s canon?
-In no case may we interpret an action as the outcome of the exercise of a higher mental faculty, if it can be interpreted as the exercise of one which stands lower in the psychological scale
-A principle in comparative psychology stating an animal’s behavior should not be explained by higher psychological processes if a simpler, lower-level process can adequately account for it
-We should prefer explanations of behavior based on the simplest mechanism
How does Lloyd Morgan’s canon relate to evolution and the phylogenetic tree?
-Provides a principle for interpreting animal behavior in light of evolutionary theory
-Use simpler and more general processes shared by many animals through evolution (vs. higher processes that evolved later due to adaptations)
What are some examples of “domain-general” processes that have been discussed so far?
Perception, memory, learning
How would Lloyd Morgan have criticized claims about the abilities of Clever Hans
Would look at the more complex process outside of the horse observing the human
What is habituation?
-An animal learns to ignore a repetitive, non-threatening stimulus after repeated exposure, resulting in a decrease in its response to that stimulus
-Learning stops because there is no surprise
What are examples of habituation?
-Adjusting to background noise
-Rattling a toy in a baby’s face
How can habituation be used to study perception?
Observe how attention decreases to a repeated stimulus and then increase to a novel one (dishabituation)
What is generalization?
A learned response to a specific stimulus or situation is applied to new, similar stimuli or situations
What are examples of generalization?
-Dog conditioned to salivate at the sound of a bell also salivates at the sound of a doorbell or car horn
-Child praised for cleaning bedroom generalizes behavior into cleaning other parts of the house
How is learning defined?
Process by which an activity orginated or is changed through reacting to an encountered situation, provided that the characteristics of the change in activity cannot be explained on the basis of native response tendencies, maturation or temporary states of the organism
What kinds of learning have we considered?
Classical conditioning and operant conditioning
What are examples of changes in behavior that are not due to learning?
Lessened responses due to native response tendencies, reflexes (blinking), maturation or temporary states (drugs, hunger, fatigue)
What are components of classical/Pavlovian conditioning?
Conditioned stimulus, conditioned response, unconditioned stimulus, unconditioned response
What is an example of classical conditioning?
-Dog salivating experiment
-US- dog food
-UR- salivation
-CS- white lab coat
-CR- salivation
What is CS?
-Conditioned stimulus
-Stimulus that did not already produce the unconditioned response
What is CS?
-Conditioned stimulus
-Stimulus that did not already produce the unconditioned response
What is CR?
-Conditioned response
-Response to the conditioned stimulus
What is US?
-Unconditioned stimulus
-A stimulus that already produces a response
What is UR?
-Unconditioned response
-The response to the stimulus, often a reflex or biologically predisposed reaction
What conditions are necessary for classical/ pavlovian conditioning to occur?
-In classical conditioning there is a change in behavior
-At least two stimuli (US and CS)
-Contiguous in time
-US is contingent on CS
-US is unexpected/ surprising
-Subject attends to CS
What is the blocking effect?
-Phenomenon in classical conditioning where prior learning to a stimulus (CS1) prevents or “blocks” the conditioning of a new, redundant stimulus (CS2) that is paired with CS1 and an unconditioned stimulus (US)
-Sequential competition
-Animals pre-trained to associate CS1 with the US do not learn a compound of CS1 and CS2