negative effects of aid
dependency
manipulate
aid = wealth = power
aid for civilians can be stolen by fights/bandits/black market
aid delivers equipment liek vehicles/radios which can be valuable to insurgents
armed escorts to facilities aid operations hav implications that need to be carefully evaluated
culture of dependency if no end state/goal
aid only given to one group/divides popuation
aid can be misued, unintended/negative consequences
Humanitarian Reform Afgenda
2005
to reform humanitarian coordination
cluster approach
reform for the international humanitarian coordination system
clusters (aid relief)
groups of humanitarian organizations (UN & non)
wach one of the main sectors for humitarian action (water, health, logistics…)
designaed byt ehe Inter-Agency Standing COmittee
IASC
inter agency standing comittee
*developed the cluster approach to humanitarian reponse b/c previous responss were disjointed. clusters provides better organization
(unorganization leads to duplications)
goal of clusters (aid relief)
achieve units of effort among responsders w/o relinquishing any of their independence
(unorganizaiton leads to duplications of efforts)
first time the cluster approach was used for humanitarian response
clusters first used in the 2005 earthquake in Pakistan
what happens when disasters don’t use a cluster system for response
chaos
confusion
competition
benefits of the cluster approach to humanitarian aid
organizations that agree to coordiante humanitarian efforts within their clusters
Lead Agency
4 aspects of stockpiling
acquire
store
preposition
distribute
aid agencies & security
aid agencies handle security differently from the military
Aid Worker Security Report & Database
in 2017, 158 major events against aid workers in 27 cuntries affected 313 aid workers
how to evaluate aid worker victims of violence
where does 2/3 of all violence against aid workers occur
SUdan Africa Syria CAR NIgeria
4 common tactics to hurt aid workers
assault explosive kidnap shoot **rape & sexual assault are underreported
3 motives for violence against aid workers
political
money
incidential (wrong place, wrong time)
who is responsible for the safety of all aid workers
host nations or occupying power are responsible for the safey of all on teh soil including guests and aid workers per the GEneva COnvention
considering when military and non-military work together to provide humanitarian aid
humanitarian organizations are distinct from military/political actors and follow humanitarian princples of impartiality, neutrality, and independence. so they can’t be complicit w/militry and polticis
fundamental policy document for UN field operations security
MOSS = Minimum Operating Security Standards
deterrance
approach to security where yu attempt to deter a threat with a counterthreat
problem of hiring private security for aid workers
may increase retaliation
affects preceived neutrality,impartiality, and operational independence of humanitarian actors
problem of military & nonmilitary working together during a humanitarian crisis
blurs lines. makes the aid agencies not appear impatial, neutral, independent
UN-CMCoord
“sim-cord”
UN Civil Military Coordination Field Handbook
*interaction betwen civilian in military actors in human itarian emergencies that is necessary to:
-protect/promote hujmanitarian principles
-avoid competition
-minimize inconsistency
-pursue common goals