sex
biological differences between males and females including chromosomes, hormones and anatomy
gender
the psychological and cultural differences between males and females including attitudes, behaviours and social roles.
sex role stereotypes
a set of beliefs and preconceived ideas about what is expected from males and females in a given society
androgyny
displaying a balance of masculine and feminine characteristics in ones personality eg women competitive at work
HOWEVER, an overrepresentation of the opposite sex does not constitute androgyny
what did Bem suggest about high androgyny
it is associated with psychological well being.
individuals who are equally masculine and feminine are better equipped to deal with a different range of situations
what was the inventory Bem created to measure gender known as and what is it
bem sex role inventory
first systematic attempt to measure androgyny using a rating scale of 60 traits (20 masc, 20 fem, 20 neutral)
produces scores over 2 dimensions;
- masculinity-femininity
- androgynous-undifferentiated
strength of androgyny and the BSRI- scale would appear to be valid and reliable
-VALID- made by asking 50 males and 50 females to take test with 200 traits, the highest scoring traits became the 60. piloted on 1000 students and correlated with their own description of gender identity
-RELIABLE- follow up study of smaller sample provided same results suggesting high test-retest reliability
what is a criticism of Bem’s idea that androgynous individuals have better psychological wellbeing
ADAM and SHEERER- those who show a greater proportion of masculine traits are better adjusted as they are more highly valued in society
Bem’s research may have not accounted for social and cultural context
limitation of androgyny and the BSRI- oversimplifies a complex concept
-too complex to be reduced to a simple score
-alternatives such as personal attribute questionnaire have been made which measures instrumentality and expressivity (however still based on idea gender can be quantified)
-GOLOMBOK and FIVUSH- gender is more global than scales, broader issues should be considered eg interests and abilities
limitation of androgyny and the BSRI- cultural and historical bias
-bsri was developed over 40 years ago and gendered behaviours have changed over time so may be outdated and lack temporal validity
-bsri was made by judges in the US, individualist definitions of ‘maleness’ and ‘femaleness’ are different to other cultures
limitation of androgyny and the BSRI- measuring gender identities using questionnaires
-relies on them fully understanding their own personality and behaviour
-self report, social desirability bias. Answer to what they think is expected of their gender
-scoring is subjective as interpretation of scale may be different between each person
what is the sex determining region Y (SRY)
-at around 6 weeks
-starts to promote the production of testosterone and other androgens
-androgens cause males to develop testes and a penis and brain to develop differently from a females
what did a males ‘connectome’ map show
showed stronger connections between front and back of the brain suggesting they are ‘better able to connect with what they see and what they do
(hunter)
what did a females ‘connectome’ map show
more wiring between left and right hemisphere in brain meaning ‘you ought be good at multitasking and may be better at emotional tasks’
oestrogen in gender
determines female characteristics and menstruation.
-increase emotionality and irritability- particularly during menstrual cycle which can sometimes be used in court
oxytocin
‘love hormone’
-women typically produce it more than men as its produced during birth to help mother-baby bonding
-men are often labelled emotionless for not producing it as much but they still experience it in intimate moments
strengths of chromosomes and hormones into explaining gender- supporting evidence (david reimer)
-david reimer- biologically male but raised female due to loss of penis, still turned to live as a man, suggesting biology has more power
strengths of chromosomes and hormones into explaining gender- supporting evidence (dabbs et al)
-DABBS et al- in prison, those with the highest testosterone= violent and sexual crimes
strengths of chromosomes and hormones into explaining gender- supporting evidence (goozen et al)
GOOZEN ET AL-
studying transgender individuals who were undergoing hormone treatment
transgender women- decrease in aggression and visuospatial skills
suggests sex hormones do exert influence on gender related behaviours
limitations of chromosomes and hormones into explaining gender- contradictory evidence
TRICKER-
in a double blind trial, 43 males were given either weekly injections of testosterone or placebo. No significant differences were found after 10 weeks in aggression levels
-also many samples of gender studies are small or unusual eg transgender so cant be applied to general population
limitations of chromosomes and hormones into explaining gender- objections to pre-menstrual syndrome
many have questioned the effect of oestrogen on women’s moods and object to medical category of PMS bc it stereotypes female experience and emotion
RODIN- PMS is a social construction to privilege men over women and also dismiss women’s emotions by explaining them biologically
limitations of chromosomes and hormones into explaining gender- overemphasis on nature
-if just biology, there would be more differences between male and female (MACCOBY and JACKLIN) found significantly more differences in behaviour within sexes than between them
-social learning theory- importance of social context when learning our gender identity and role, which would explain cross cultural differences and rise in androgyny
approaches
limitations of chromosomes and hormones into explaining gender- oversimplifies complex concept
-only focuses on biological factors
-cognitive approach- children actively construct their gender through maturation, not passive socialisation
-psychodynamic approach- childhood experiences
what is klinefelter syndrome and how many does it affect
-1 in 500 men
-develop an extra x chromosome