can the plaintiff ever really remove a case in civ pro?
no theyre the master of the lawsuit. the defendant can remove shit not the plaintiff. why would u file a lawsuit somewhere and then try to move it get fucked
can a defendant remove to their home state in a diversity action?
no. fed court is less biased venue anyway, but you can’t like. have home court advantage.
BUT IN A FEDERAL QUESTION ACTION THE DEFENDANT CAN REMOVE TO THE STATE THEY ARE FROM THEY WILL TRY TO TRICK U W THIS
federal question case: can defendant remove to the same state theyre from?
yes
federal diversity case: can defendant remove to the same theyre from?
no
how many days to remove?
30
anytime a judge makes a choice on some shit to do, the standard of review will be:
abuse of discretion
how can you tell if there’s an abuse of discretion review question afoot
the word permitted . fr fr
default judgment means what
mofo just didnt even show up to defend their case. thats it. who can enter the judgment? judge or clerk
what does “tried to the court” mean?
bench trial
whats up w bench trials
FRCP 52(a)(1) says judge needs to “find the facts specially and state the conclusions of law separately.” doesnt have to be in writing orally is fine
-just watch out for judges saying like heres da judgment, later! nope not allowed. he needs to talk about why he ruled so the parties can appeal later on if need be
rules re: voluntary dismissal
-u get one voluntary dismissal
-try it again no more refile babes - operates as an adjudication on the merits
mistake, fraud, newly discovered evidence: how long do u have to bring it back up ie motions for relief?
1 year
if the judge lets in bad evidence and u lose, whats the best way to attack the verdict?
motion for a new trial! u get one if:
-jury does some crazy shit
-judge fucks up
-jury gives u wayyyyy too high verdict like wtf
can u move for RJMOL without first having moved for JMOL?
fuuuuuck no. what are you even renewing then? no
how do u win a RJMOL?
-more than a mere scintilla of evidence
RJMOL = SS
substantial or scintila
conduct speech test for o’brien
substantial
legal standard for JMOL
LARGE SNAKES EAT BORDS
-LEGALLY
-SUFFICIENT
-EVIDENTIARY
-BASIS
can u extend an RJMOL motion??
no u get 28 days and that is it. FRCP says no extnesion
legal standard for Summary Judgment
GDMF.- god damn mother fucker
-genuine
-dispute of
-material
-fact
how is a judgment on the pleadings decided?
judge rules on case by only looking at complaint and answer
ALL PLEADINGS MUST BE FILED
AND
U GOTTA FILE AN ANSWER TO THAT COUNTERCLAIM BEFORE U CAN FILE A JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS THE END
didnt object? what is ur only recourse
plain error. they will test this.
can u have fewer than 6 jurors??
yeah if everyone agrees on it
doesnt have to be unanimous either
but not for criminal trials - then u need at least 6 and they must be unanimous fr
are u guaranteed a right to a jury trial in equitable actions?
nope
when do u file to demand a jury trial?
14 days after defendant files answer
if the defendant never files the answer the clock starts ticking