3 Theories of MCS
Agency Theory
P-A relationship where P assigns responsibility to A and A is contracted to work on behalf of P
Problems: actions unobservable, self interest of A (max wealth), dislike work assignment
Control mechanism: monitoring and/ or incentive compensation
Expectancy Theory
People are motivated to get rewards they want and prevent penalties they wish to avoid
Motivate people to behave in a particular way; therefore, employment must contain 1) desirable rewards and the probability that efforts lead to performance, which leads to rewards
Equity Theory
Perceived under-or-over rewarded will experience distress, leading to efforts to restore equity
Where Individual outputs/ owns inputs = relational outputs/ inputs
Inputs: time, effort, loyalty, enthusiasm,etc
Output: love, intimacy, esteem , salary, etc
Limitations of MCS
Corporate citizenship
NFPO
Values and core beliefs
Pride and accomplishment
Factors Influencing Goal Congruence: Informal and Formal
Informal Factors
External value: work ethic (loyalty, diligence, social value)
Internal value: History and top management leadership style (common belief, attitudes, norms, relationships, assumptions)
Formal Factors:
Rules: Job descriptions, manuals, SOP, etc
MCS
Types of Control Diagram
Goals -> Strategy -> Operating Activities -> 3 Main: Results, Action, Personnel/ Culture
Performance Measurement Framework
Results Control
Rewards individuals for good results (or punishing them for poor results).
- Results accountability
How does Results Control Influence Actions
Employees are concerned about the consequences of the actions they take.
However, employees’ actions are not constrained;
They will also take action for what they believe will best produce the desired results.
Elements of Effective Results Control (4)
Results: Defining the performance dimensions
Measurement MATTERS!
If not congruent with the organization’s objectives, the controls will actually encourage employees to do the wrong things!
Results: Measuring performance on these dimensions
Objective
Financial: market-based (e.g., stock price) or accounting-based (e.g., ROA)
Non-financial (e.g., market share, customer turnover, customer satisfaction)
Subjective: managerial characteristics (e.g., critical thinking, being a team player)
Results: Setting performance targets
Motivational effects
Providing Rewards (or punishments)
monetary or non-monetary
Conditions for Effective Results Control from manager and individual
All 3 must be present:
Actions Controls
Ensure that employees perform (or do not perform) certain actions known to be beneficial (or harmful)to the organization.
Prevention/ detection:
Most action controls are aimed at preventingundesirable behaviors
Elements of Effective Action Control
How does management observe or otherwise track what happens?
When do “managers” know an Action Control Effective?
Behavioural Constraints: Action Control
Physical
Locks, passwords, and limited access.
Administrative
Restriction of decision-making authority;
Separation of duties.
Pre-Action Review
Scrutiny of action plans, investment proposals, budgets
Review and approval