What are the 2 main approaches to using gene therapy for treating or preventing genetic disorders
Counteracting recessive disorders
Silencing faulty dominant alleles
How can gene therapy treat genetic disorders
Identify the abnormal gene responsible for the disorder
Engineer normal, functional versions of this gene by removing it from healthy cells or synthesis in lab
Deliver normal allele to nuclei of target cells using vector
What is somatic gene therapy
Replaces mutant alleles with healthy alleles in affected body cells to treat diseases
What are the target cells of SCGT
Somatic (body cells)
Are gene modifications inherited by offspring in SCGT
No
What is germline gene therapy
Involves inserting healthy allele into embryo to prevent genetic diseases from birth
What are target cells for germline therapy
Germ cells (egg/sperm)
Embryos
Are modifications inherited in germline therapy
Yes
What are the general ethical issues of both gene therapies
Potential misuse for enhancing aesthetic attributes rather than medical needs
Risk of causing unintended harm
Diverts scarce healthcare resources
High in cost - restricts access
What are the ethical benefits of gene therapy
Extends lives by treating diseases
Enhances quality of life
Germline allows carrier parents to have children free from genetic disorders
What are the ethical issues with SCTC
Delivering healthy alleles to cells is challenging
Getting healthy alleles into the nucleus is challenging
Maintaining the expression of healthy alleles is challenging
Effects are short term as semantic cells have limited lifespan and are replaced by cells with the faulty allele
Ethical issues with germline therapy
Rights of unborn child are violated - cannot provide consent
Causes irreversible changes - long term outcomes not fully understood
Could be used to select desirable traits
Advantages of GM crops
Involves less labour than traditional herbicides and pesticides
Cheaper than these
Herbicide resistant allow use of herbicides to kill weeds without harming crop - ^ yield
Insect resistant less likely to be killed by pests - ^ yield
Insect resistant reduce need for pesticides, benefiting environment
Disadvantages of GM crops
Encourages monocultures - reducing biodiversity
Herbicide resistant may cross breed with wild plants, creating herbicide resistant weeds
Loss of traditional crop varieties - reducing genetic diversity - makes vulnerable to disease & climate changes
Non target insects could be harmed by toxin coded for by insect resistant crops
Advantages of GM farmed animals
Improves quality (enhance disease resistance)
Improves quantity (enables year round reproduction)
Improves productivity (faster growth)
What is pharming
Involves production of pharmaceuticals & human medicines by inserting human genes into other animals, allowing for extraction of pharmaceutical proteins from GM animals’ milk/blood at ^ yields
Advantages of pharming
Enables mass production of rare treatments
Makes drugs more accessible
Disadvantages of pharming
Raises animal welfare concerns
Can lead to animals being viewed solely as commodities
Advantages of GM pathogens
Offers potential treatments for diseases prev deemed incurable
Can produce essential medicines, antibiotics and enzymes eg insulin
Useful in creating vaccines
Facilitates creation of DNA libraries for reseach
Disadvantages of GM pathogens
Carries risk of accidental infections and disease outbreaks
Danger that engineered pathogens could revert to original harmful form
Could be misused in biological warfare
What are the ethical concerns with patenting GM organisms
Legal patenting raises questions about global access
Affects smallholder farmers in developing countries who may be unable to afford patented seeds due to high costs
What is genetic engineering
Deliberate manipulation of genetic material to modify an organisms’ characteristics
What is recombinant DNA
DNA altered to contain nucleotides from 2 different organisms
Allows DNA fragments to be transferred between organisms
What are the key stages of gene transfer