Who is the speaker and what is she talking about?
mother talking about her mother whose died
What are the themes
nostalgia and grief
What are the handkerchiefs an extended metaphor for?
care
‘My mother was a hanky queen’
old form of parenting was a permanent time taking care juxtaposing the speaker modern disposable ‘tissues’ care suggesting there is a deprecation of significance towards parenting
‘she’d have one, always, up her sleeve’
emphasises the speaker’s view of her mother as a better parent causing her grief and she critiques herself
What is the effect of speaker using names like ‘Viv’, the ‘greengrocer George’ , ‘Mrs White’ in comparison to the ‘closed department stores’
The speaker employs proper nouns when discussing the memory of the past suggesting things were more personal and substantial compared to modern day which is more disposable
‘spittled and scrubbed’
sibilance emphatic of hands on parenting and care
‘And sometimes more than one [hankerchief] fell out as if she has a farm up there’
simile reemphasises care and nurturing
‘She bought her own; I never did’
caesura emphatic of separation and change she is no longer able to return to the past
‘presents from distant aunts’
underlying tone surfacing of parenting being a womanly job
‘my brothers too… got males ones: serious and grey’
criticism of gender roles through colour imagery suggesting gender roles are outdated
‘Hankies… shuttered the doors of family stores’
refernece to family shows the previous care in generations and highlights tradition fading and disappearing
Why does the speaker use a regular rhyme scheme?
to portray it as formal and regimented creating a sense of the past
‘step-together, step-together, step-together’
repetition highlighting how women had to conform to female roles within society showing a shift in the speaker’s tone form grief to releasing the indication of gender roles within the past
‘Nostalgia only makes me old.’
Volta and change in tone as the speaker no longer adapts a praising nostalgic tone and the end stop emphasises the change being final
‘eat bought bicuits’
contrast in parenting style as modern one seems more impersonal and detached
‘There’s never a hanky up my sleeve. I raised neglected-looking kids,’
extended metaphor of tissues as her parenting is less substantial with less involvement than former parenting
‘But it isn’t mine. I’ll let it go’
argument marker creates a sense of healing and forgiving which the caesura emphasises a moment of reflection. The end stop portrays her acceptance of differences in parenting