What is law and society?
multidisciplinary study of the relationship between law and society
Why is the definition of law highly disputed?
It is not observable, it is unclear in nature
Definition of Law
Set of rules and regulations governing a society
Modern Law is what two things?
Explicit - clear, codified
Binding - materially enforceable
Is social law binding or non-binding?
Social law is non-binding, and is socially enforced (like becoming an outcast)
Definition of society
ordered web of ties that includes relationships and institutions
contains a social system, but is beyond it
What is an institution?
anything that shapes, constrains or guides human behaviour
institutions are structures
What is the structure agency debate
institutions are not agents
institutions do not make the rules
agency has will to make decisions
the law itself is not an agent
Hard vs Soft power
hard power would be coerce (police force with weapons)
soft power would be to persuade (such as an instructor guiding belief)
Three kinds of power
Instrumental - hard power
Ideological - soft power
Structural - blantant powerW
What is an example of Structural power in alberta?
oil companies, politicians and policy makers must respect their desires
Four functions of the law
Dispute resolution
Social control
Social change
Justice
What is justice?
To give each person their due, however this is very dependant on interpretation
what is theory?
set of assumptions of how thins work
it is falsifiable
needs possibility of being wrong
liberalism
individual freedoms are morally right, dominant political philosophy in modern history
what perspective is “an unjust law is no law at all”?
legal naturalism
Natural law
there is universal, absolute law (morals)
What is legal positivism
what is right is what is lawful
social contract
benifits everyone, involves social deterance
legal realism
focuses on understanding legal outcomes
big emphasis on analysis
marxism
historical materialism, emphasis on economic determinism and class relations
critial legal theory
anything about power is critical legal theory
views power as embedded in the legal system
Carter V canada
Maid, charter challenge to existing maid law
Liebeck vs McDonalds
Product liability case
negligence / punitive damage
mcdonalds was in bad faith -> Liebeck got more money than requested