Alexander “The New Jim Crow” main argument
mass incarceration functions as a comprehensive system of racialized social control to maintain racial hierarchy
The system uses the race-neutral label of “felon” to authorize the same legal discriminations (denial of voting, housing, employment) that were once used explicitly based on race under Jim Crow
why is the criminal justice system a “gateway” into permanent undercaste/underworld (Alexander)
once released, former prisoners enter an “underworld” of legalized discrimination and permanent social exclusion (voting, access to housing or employment)
Covert “The Court Watch Movement Wants To Expose The ‘House of Cards’” main argument
that the criminal legal system is a “house of cards” propped up by the public’s lack of understanding of its daily operations.
Once people appreciate the reality of these operations, the system will be forced to change
what is the court watch movement
group of volunteers sent to city courtrooms to observe what happens and gather data (origin in Chicago)
what was the outcome of the court watching program
giving the public an understanding of what goes on inside city courtrooms
court watch key findings
bail-setting varies by judge, cases often acts of desperation and poverty, majority of cases are nonviolent, majority of cases = POC, bail is more likely when requested by district attorney
what does Covert mean by the power of visibility
the presence of watchers can shift power and force accountability, leading to more favorable outcomes for defendants
Davis “From the Prison of Slavery to the Slavery of Prison: Frederick Douglass and the Convict Lease System” main argument
13th Amendment loophole allowed the South to re-enslave Black people by allowing slavery as punishment for a crime via the convict lease system
what were Frederick Douglass’s political beliefs
believed in the establishment (that we could work out racial issues through the system) and that overtime (post-slavery era), Black people would be less and less criminalized
what are the black codes
southern laws that criminalized vagrancy, breech of job contracts, absence from work, possession of firearms, and insulting gestures or acts
why were black codes racist
nullified black people’s new judicial status as US citizens and racialized crimes (only black people could be charged)
what did the Thirteenth Amendment do
abolished slavery and involuntary servitude
Thirteenth Amendment loophole
crimes were punishable by incarceration and forced labor
what are the two theories of the convict lease system
1: labor control, “crime” increased in areas with business contracts (mining, tree removal, railroad, expansion, etc.)
2: racial domination: harsh treatment of minority groups increased in areas where minorities posed a threat (convict leasing used most in counties where Black people were establishing own farms and businesses; urban areas used more than rural)
why does Davis disagree with Douglass
She critiques his “absolute faith” in legal reform and Enlightenment principles, which she argues blinded him to the way legal institutions were complicit in re-enslaving Black people via the convict lease system
why did douglass focus on lynching
because it was outside the pale of the law, thus unlawful by nature; victims were divested of the right to confront their accusers
Herring “Complaint-Oriented Policing: Regulating Homelessness in Public Space” main argument
complaint-oriented policing results in burden shuffling, where police move the unhoused from one block to another rather than providing housing
what is complaint-oriented policing
residents and businesses can call the police to “deal with” homelessness; homeless crisis fueled by an increase in these complaints rather than an actual increase in homelessness
what is pervasive penality
policing through move-along orders, citations, and threats of arrests
what are the three aspects/components of pervasive penality
what is the impact of policing homelessness on inequality
criminalized poverty, treating homelessness as a nuisance, resulting in legal action rather than addressing the root causes
what is aggressive policing
Left hand: nurture and provide via education, welfare, and medical care
Right hand: sternness and discipline via police, courts, and prison
what is therapeutic policing
balancing the part of the state that protects people (left hand) and the part that disciplines (right hand)
what is neoliberalism
economic restructuring in 1970s and 1980s: free market system based in minimal government intervention (deregulation of industry and deindustrialization, limited labor protections, privatization of risk)
believed untrue –> rather the state is interventionist