Commanding Heights
Economic sectors the government believes must be under public control because they are foundational to national power and economic development.
Examples of Commanding Heights
Energy (oil, electricity)
Heavy industry
Transportation (railroads, airlines)
Banking/Finance
Defense Industries
Artificial Inteligence (AI)
Space Exploration
Rare minerals
Characteristics of Commanding Heights
1) Structurally central to the economy
2) Linked to national power or sovereignty
3) Affect national security
4) Shape political and social order
5) Often resemble natural monopolies
6) Involves long term strategic investment
Guarded Globalization
States allow markets and cross-border economic activity — but only under political conditions that protect regime stability, national power, or strategic control.
Factors Countries with Guarded Globalization take into account
1) The countries or regions with which to do business
2) The sectors in which they will allow capital investment
3) The local (often state affiliated) companies to promote
How businesses can navigate a guarded globalized future
Entrepreneurial State (Leader in Markets)
When the government is a leader and cooperates with private companies in the market.
Tend to be the first to do something because of various resources they have, which private companies do NOT have.
Policy “Prescriptions” (Recommendations) for Entrepreneurial States
State as a Hindrance in Markets
A skeptical POV that demonstrates that states can also create “non-market” failures.
State will NOT ALWAYS succeed where the private sector fails
4 Types of Non-Market Failures
Market Failure: Internalities
When organizational concerns are included in the work public sector employees do, which can wash off the work they do to solve societal needs.
Examples:
- Internal Goals
- Motivations
- Standards of public agencies
Market Failure: Redundant & Rising Costs
Ex: Hard to fire people
Market Failure: Derived Externalities (NEED HELP UNDERSTANDING THIS ONE)
Market Failure: Distributional Inequity in Influence/Power
Ex: Voting, taxes, wage changes
Types of Market Elements that fuels non-market failures
State as a Facilitator
State as a Corrector
Provides public goods and common goods for the public.
^^Because private failures lead to inequities and market imperfections
Factors that determine rivalrousness and excludability of goods
-Not static
- Socially constructed
- Could be partially rivalrous or excludable
Keynes Critique of Laissez-Faire
Friedman & Friedman
*Liberalist ideology
Critique of Keynesianism (Friedman)
1) Government too involved
2) Sometimes only special interests are considered
- end up furthering the general interest
3) Political invisible hand
- rhetoric about general interest ends up rewarding special interests
Economic Bill of Rights (Friedman & Friedman)
1) Tax and spending limits
2) Reductions in tariffs, wage, and price controls
3) Flat income tax
4) Inflation Management
LONG TERM GOAL= TO CHANGE MINDSET
- because society has normalized centralizing power to any entity (government included)
Mixed Economy (Yergin-Stanislaw)
An economic system in which both markets and the state play significant roles in allocating resources
NOT AN IDEOLOGY
Views government as a facilitator and corrector
Defined by institutional structure:
- some sectors private and others public
- government influences markets
Mixed Economy’s Main Policy Tools (Yergin-Stanislaw)
1) Regulation
- ex: tariffs
2) Keynesian fiscal management
- ex: government involved in national monetary management
- ex: department of treasury
3) Monetary policy
4) Planning
- deciding what economic priorities important now
- pipeline of workers (STEM in education)
- what needs more resources
5) Industrial Policy
- government picking areas “winners” have most impact/potential
6) State ownership
- ex: national oil companies, postal service (USPS), transportation