What is Euthypro trying to discuss?
What is holiness
What is Euthyphro’s first definition?
Gods love x is the reason for x being holy
What is Socrates criticism of the first definition?
Why do the gods love what is holy? The gods must have a reason for loving what is holy.
What is Euthyphro’s second definition?
Holiness is whatever is pleasing to all gods
What is Socrates criticism of the second definition?
It’s a circular argument, gods love holiness because it is holy.
What is the divine command theory?
Whatever is morally right is right because god commanded it
What is socartes critisim of the divine command theory?
2. there is no reason and god can make anything permissible