Formation of lawyer-client relationship
A lawyer-client relationship is formed when a client reasonably believes that the lawyer is providing legal services on their behalf.
Lawyer’s Duty to Clients
Lawyers owe clients a basic duty of loyalty and independent professional judgment.
Duty of loyalty
A lawyer must act in the client’s best interests, avoid conflicts of interest, and not represent adverse interests without informed written consent.
Attorney-client privilege (definition)
Privilege protects confidential communications between a lawyer and client made for the purpose of obtaining or providing legal advice. Applies when the client reasonably believes the lawyer represents them and intends confidentiality.
Attorney-client privilege: Who holds privilege
The client holds the privilege.
Attorney-client privilege: Duration
Privilege continues indefinitely, surviving the end of representation and even the client’s death.
Attorney-client privilege exceptions
Duty of Confidentiality (general rule)
A lawyer must not disclose information relating to representation unless the client gives informed consent or disclosure is impliedly authorized.
Duty of confidentiality exceptions: Prevent substantial financial harm
A lawyer may disclose to prevent substantial financial harm caused by criminal acts of the client or a third party.
Duty of confidentiality exceptions: Prevent death or serious injury
A lawyer may disclose to prevent reasonably certain death or serious bodily harm.
Duty of confidentiality exceptions: Lawyer-client controversy
May disclose to establish a claim/defense in a dispute with a client or respond to allegations concerning representation.
Duty of confidentiality exceptions: Secure legal advice
A lawyer may reveal confidential information to secure legal advice about compliance with the rules.
Duty of confidentiality exceptions: Compliance with law or court order
A lawyer may disclose when required by law or court order.
Duty of confidentiality: Scope
Covers privileged information and all information relating to representation, including observations and third-party communications.
Duty of confidentiality: Prospective client
A lawyer may not use or reveal information learned from a prospective client, even if no relationship forms.
Prospective client exception: No reasonable expectation
A person who unilaterally communicates without a reasonable expectation of representation is not a prospective client.
Informed consent (definition)
Consent given after the lawyer communicates all material risks and reasonable alternatives.
Informed consent: When NOT allowed
Not allowed if representation violates law/RPC, involves one client asserting a claim against another in the same matter, or the lawyer cannot provide adequate representation.
Implied authority to disclose
Disclosure is allowed when impliedly authorized to carry out representation or when sharing with lawyers in the same firm, unless the client instructs otherwise.
Third-party presence and privilege
Privilege is destroyed if a non-necessary third party is present, unless they assist communication or are a representative.
Duty of communication
A lawyer must keep the client reasonably informed, respond to requests, and explain matters to allow informed decisions.
Competence
Competent representation requires legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation. Lawyers may accept cases if competence can be achieved through preparation or association.
Scope and authority
Client determines objectives; lawyer determines means, after consultation.
Diligence
A lawyer must act with reasonable diligence and promptness and must not willfully abandon a matter.