present estates overview & restraint on alienation
*restraint on alienation: a grantor can place a reasonable restraint on the grantee’s ability to feely transfer, but a restraint on alienation is generally void when it purports to prohibit alienation of the estate and render any conveyance by the grantee void
*When the terms of a conveyance are ambiguous, courts typically adopt a preference for a fee simple subject to condition subsequent.
absolute ownership
largest possessory state, capable of lasting forever
if ambiguous grant, creates fee simple
“O to A” means same thing as “O to A and his heirs”
ownership terminates if a condition occurs and passes automatically to grantor
look for durational words: “as long as,” “until”
possibility of reverter is a future interest automatically retained by the grantor that becomes possessory upon the occurrence of the stated condition in a FSD
*“for the purpose of” is an FSA, not FSD
when the condition occurs, the grantor can exercise a right of reentry (not automatic)
look for conditional words (“but if” “on condition” “provided that”) and words such as “right to reenter”
freely alienable by owner during his life, and upon his death is devisable and descendible
*The grantor must explicitly retain the right to terminate the fee simple subject to condition subsequent in the conveyance. Owner may or may not have a right to terminate, depending on whether the court would be willing to imply a forfeiture provision when none was expressly set forth in the deed.
will end upon the happening of an event and the future interest will vest in a third party
held by the another transferee, not the grantor
“to A, but if liquor is served, then to B” –> B has an executory interest
springing executory interest: divests the grantor
shifting executory interest: divests a prior grantee
ownership terminates upon the end of the measuring life
“for life”
can’t pass by will or intestate succession
future interest:
*required to pay property taxes but limited to financial benefit from property (if living there, measured by reasonable rental value of property)
concurrent estates overview
*the default concurrent interest
each tenant owns a separate but undivided interest in the entire property (can possess the whole)
this interest is freely devisable or transferable
right of survivorship: when one joint tenant ides, the interest goes to the other joint tenants
must have express language creating a joint tenancy along with survivorship language
must have 4 unities (PITT): possession, interest, time, title
-each joint tenant has equal right to possess the whole property, interest equal to others, at the same time, and in the same instrument
severance of joint tenancy:
joint tenancy btw spouses (marriage is 5th unity)
each co-tenant has the right to possess the entire property
ouster: a co-tenant who is being denied access can bring a court action to regain access to the property
adverse possession: if one co-tenant ousted the other, he can make a claim for AP if he meets the requirements
a co-tenant does not owe rent for his use of the property
a co-tenant must share rents received from 3rd parties (divided based on ownership interest)
necessary charges, such as taxes or mortgage interest payment
a co-tenant can collect contribution for other co-tenants for payments in excess of her share of operating expenses
*however, a co-tenant in sole possession can collect only for the amount that exceeds the rental value of the property
repairs:
improvements:
partition:
types of leaseholds
tenant’s duties
pay rent, avoid waste, and make reasonable repairs
withholding/deduction of rent
-if landlord breaches covenant of quiet enjoyment or implied warranty of habitability
waste: tenant cannot damage the property and must repair damage he causes
- can’t commit affirmative or permissive waste, but can make ameliorative waste (improve, usually require permission, and can be prohibited in lease)
failure to pay rent: landlord can sue for damages & eviction
abandonment: if tenant abandons the property, landlord can accept as an offer of surrender
landlord duties overview
landlord must repair damages under residential leases, unless the tenant caused the damages
landlord must maintain the property such that it is reasonably suited for residence
-e.g. failure to provide heat, electricity, running water, or plumbing
failing to comply with housing codes is a breach, especially violations related to health or safety
tenant must give notice to landlord and reasonable opportunity to repair
if landlord fails to make repairs, tenant may:
*applies to residential & commercial leases
the landlord must not disrupt the tenant’s possession or enjoyment of the property
-controls common areas & nuisance of other tenants
actual eviction: landlord must remove tenant from premises
partial eviction: tenant prevented from possessing/using portion of leased premises
-excused from paying rent for entire premises if landlord responsible for partial eviction
constructive eviction:
assignment/sublease
assignment:
- a transfer of the tenant’s remaining lease to a new party
- generally allowed, unless prohibited by lease
- landlord can collect rent from tenant or subsequent tenant
sublease:
prohibition clauses: a clause in the lease prohibiting assignment or sublease
duty to mitigate damages
landlord has duty to make reasonable efforts to re-rent the property to mitigate the damages from tenant leaving early/evicted
(doesn’t under minority rule, more common in commercial leases)
adverse possession
allows person in unlawful possession (trespasser) to acquire good title
ECHO: exclusive, continuous, hostile, open & notorious
valid deed requirements
must identify the property and the parties, must be signed, and must include words of transfer
rule: to transfer a real property interest, the grantor must demonstrate the intent to make a present transfer of the interest and the grantee must accept the interest. in addition, pursuant to the SoF, the transfer of real property must be evidenced by a writing. must include all necessary terms such as grantor’s signature, named grantee, words of transfer, and a description of property. consideration is not required