Front
Back
Myth: Protester identity is uniform
Stereotypes are misleading; protesters come from diverse backgrounds and motives.
Myth: Everyone feels the same about protest
Public attitudes vary by protest type and climate views; those rating climate change as very important find protests more justifiable.
Myth: Protesters don’t understand public views
False—activists’ estimates of public support often match actual views (Feinberg, Willer & Kovacheff, 2020).
Myth: Unpopular protest turns people away
People misattribute reasons for attitude change; explanations follow cultural logic (Nisbett & Wilson, 1977).
Historical view of protest
Protest is often seen as the engine of social change (e.g., suffragettes), but historians disagree on effectiveness.
Pugh (2012) finding on suffragettes
Militancy damaged the cause.
Whitfield (2001) on suffragettes
Militant actions set back women’s suffrage progress.
Affective Model (Selvanathan & Lickel, 2019)
Protest evokes emotions → empowerment → stronger movement identity → support for social change.
Evidence for Affective Model
Emotional pathways matter for support.
Social Identification Model (Feinberg et al., 2020)
Extreme protest risks the ‘activist’s dilemma’: backlash instead of support.
Evidence for Social Identification Model
Protests can reduce identification if perceived as immoral.
Experiment 1 (Mann et al.)
Positive vs. negative protest framing alters support for actions, movement, and demands.
Experiment 2 (Mann et al.)
Framing effects on moral perception and support replicated in Poland.
Experiment 3 (Mann et al.)
Negative framing → protests seen as more immoral and less identifiable.
Experiment 3 – demand support
No significant impact on demand support or climate concern.
Framing effect overall
Framing shifts emotions and morality judgments more than policy views.
Example of political backlash
Lord Callanan (2022): ‘They’re giving insulation a bad name.’
Key takeaway: Public support
Depends on protest type, framing, and prior attitudes.
Key takeaway: Activist perception accuracy
Activists understand public opinion better than assumed.
Key takeaway: Framing effects
Framing shapes emotional and moral responses more than policy views.
Key takeaway: Unpopular protest
May draw attention and highlight injustice but risks backlash.
Key takeaway: Historical evidence
Protest effectiveness is complex; outcomes depend on context and perception.
Study: Feinberg, Willer & Kovacheff (2020)
Extreme protest may backfire due to reduced public support.
