Sale
- 2 parties : Seller (Vendor) and Buyer (Vendee)
- what is the obligation of seller? of buyer?
Seller - to transfer ownership + to deliver determinate thing
Buyer - to pay a price certain in money
Characteristics of Contract (BCCNOP)
Service can be an object in a contract of sale. True or False?
Indeterminate thing may be an object in a contract of sale. True or False?
False (only thing or right)
- since purpose is to transfer ownership
True (Generally : Determinate Thing)
- However, indeterminate thing who are physically segregated → determinate na → can be an object in a contract of sale
Another Requisites of Object
- must be within commerce of men (licit)
- seller must have a right to transfer ownership at time it is delivered
Things subject to a resolutory condition, since it will be extinguished, may not be an object. True or False?
at time it is delivered (not perfection)
False → it may be an object (e.g. right of repurchase)
From the flashcard above, it stated “at time it is delivered”. Thus, future goods can be an object in a contract of sale.
Other term for “sale of future things”
Emptio Rei Speratae - valid
Future Thing → must come into existence = X void
Other term for “sale of hope or expectancy”
Sale of vain hope is valid. True or False?
Emptio Spei - valid
- example → lotto ticket
Vain Hope - void
Hope → no need to come into existence (since hope yung binili)
Can future inheritance, being a future thing, be an object in a contract of sale?
NO
In a contract of sale, the cause we are talking about is “price”.
YES
Price must be certain
- fixed by the parties
- with reference to another thing certain
- determination of price is left to will of a 3rd person
What will happen if the 3rd party is in bad faith or mistake?
What will happen if the 3rd party is prevented by the seller/buyer?
What will happen if the 3rd party is unwilling or unable to determine a price?
Fulfillment + Damage
Rescission + Damage
Gross inadequacy of price does not affect a contract of sale. True or False?
False (Generally : True)
- However, if there’s a defect in consent or the parties really intended it to be a donation → it affects the contract of sale
Kinds as to Transfer of Ownership
- Absolute
- Conditional
What about contract to sell?
Absolute
- transfer of ownership → upon delivery, even if payment is not yet complete
Conditional
- transfer of ownership → upon fulfillment of condition
Contract to Sell → is a conditional sale. However, transfer of ownership → upon execution of a deed of sale
Contract of Sale or Agency to Sell
- there is transfer of onwership
Contract of Sale
- Agency to Sell → no transfer (only right to sell property)
Contract of Sale or Agency to Sell
- after delivery, buyer bears the risk of loss
Contract of Sale
- Agency to Sell → risk of loss remains to the principal (not transferred to the agent)
Contract of Sale or Contract for Piece of Work
- special order
Contract for Piece of Work
- Contract of Sale → in the ordinary course of business (whether on hand or not - kahit di pa napproduce)
In a sense, parang same lang yung contract of sale at yung contract for piece of work. Bakit need pa sila idistinguish sa isa’t-isa?
Contract of Sale = covered by Statute of Frauds
Contract for Piece of Work = X
Kaya if ever may sale of real property na P300 lang at contract for piece of work yon, valid pa rin siya (hindi unenforceable)
If consideration is partly in money, partly in kind. Is it a contract of sale or barter?
Depends
1. Intention of Parties
2. If intention is not clear
a. Thing > (it is a barter)
b. Thing ≤ (it is a sale)
Example
- money = 5,000
- in kind = 5,000
This is a “sale” since less than or equal to. If the value of in kind is 5,001, it is a “barter”
If the promise to buy and/or sell is bilateral (mutual promise), it is reciprocally demandable. True or False?
If the promise to buy and/or sell is unilateral, and it is not accepted by the offeree, there is a contract. True or False?
True
False (there is no contract)
If the promise to buy and/or sell is unilateral, and it is accepted by the offeree, it is already binding to the offeror. True or False?
Depends
NOTE : However, if acceptance is already communicated → cannot withdraw
- whether with option money or not
- since “perfected” already (no option anymore)
Always remember to look out for this.
Sale - period to pay
Option - period to decide
YES
If you pay earnest money, it is a proof of a perfected contract of sale. True or False?
True “earnest” kaya magiging part siya ng purchase price
- Option → no perfected sale yet (not part of purchase price unless agreed)
Option Money → separate consideration for “period” to accept / withdraw offer
Sale by Auction
- perfection → fall of hammer
- before perfection
(1) bidder → may cancel bid
(2) seller → may withdraw goods
Does a seller has a right to bid?
No
- XPN : (1) notice → given to bidders
- XPN : (2) right to bid → expressly reserved
- XPN : (3) not prohibited by law
Sale of Goods
Description OR Sample
- description do not correspond → rescind
- sample do not correspond → rescind
Description AND Sample
- description + sample do not correspond → rescind
Yes
Obligations of the Vendor
- to take care of the thing
- to pay taxes related to sale
- to warrant the thing
Loss of Thing Awaiting Delivery
- Entirely lost → contract = no efffect
- Partly lost → (1) withdraw (2) demand remaining part
- Deteriorated without knowledge of Seller
(1) void
(2) valid (those not deteriorated)
Yes