Lease
Art. 2A covers leases and subleases of goods (NOT REAL PROPERTY), defined as a transfer of the right to possession and use of goods for a term in return for consideration
Lease vs. Disguised Sale on Credit
A contract is a disguised sale on credit if the “lessee” has no right to terminate his obligation to pay during the lease term and:
Factors that do not indicate a sale
Statute of Frauds: Leases
A lease must be in writing if the total of payments under the lease will be $1,000 or more. The writing must be signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought, describe the leased goods and lease term, and indicate that a lease contract has been made between the parties. Lease must specify the quantity of leased goods.
Battle of the Forms
Art. 2A has no battle of the forms provision
Consumer Protection
If lessee is consumer, a consumer lease arises and the following special rules apply:
b. Attorney’s Fees - In consumer lease litigation, successful consumer may recover attorney’s fees, but a consumer who knowingly brings a groundless suit can be held liable for the lessor’s attorney’s fees
Lease Warranties
Finance Lease (e.g., bank buys car and leases to consumer) Warranties - Any warranties made by supplier to lessor are passed on to lessee, so lessee may sue the supplier
Lessee can refuse to pay lessor on nonconsumer finance lease when goods are not accepted
Hell or High Water Clause - Imposes absolute obligation on lessee to make payments no matter how badly the leased goods perform or break down. DOES NOT APPLY TO CONSUMER LEASES.
Remedies
Default by Lessor - Same as Art. 2: Accept the goods and recover damages or reject goods and cover or seek market price-lease differential)
Default by Lessee - Lessor may cancel lease contract, withhold delivery, take possession of previously delivered goods, stop delivery of goods by a bailee, dispose of or retain the goods and recover damages, recover rent, or exercise any other rights or pursue any other remedies specifically provided for in the lease contract
Damages are limited to actual damages caused by the breach except for lost volume sellers
Ability to Sublease
Subleasing is allowed, even despite an agreement to the contrary. But if the transfer is a material violation of the prime lease, it is grounds for a default
Sublessee entitled to same rights
Assignment of Right of Payment Allowed
When lessor has no remaining significant affirmative duties (“non-operating lease”) the right to payment may be transferred despite agreement to the contrary, even if it would otherwise be grounds for default
Basic Approach for Commercial Paper Issues
Note
A promise to pay money made from a maker (promisor, obligor) to a payee (promisee)
A note issued by a bank is called a Certificate of Deposit
Draft
Order to pay (3-party instrument) involving the drawer (person ordering payment), drawee (person to make the payment; payor in check context), and payee (person who receives the payment)
Checks
Requirements: Bank is drawee and payable on demand
Types of Checks:
Remotely-Created Item
A draft not signed by the drawer but created with drawers authority so that a third party can get paid from the drawers account at a bank
Third party is usually a seller in an internet transaction or when you pay bills over the telphone by giving creditor your checking account number
Negotiability
Refers to the form of the instrument
If paper is negotiable, and reaches the hands of a Holder in Due Course (HDC), HDC obtains better rights than transferor and thus can get paid from obligor even though the obligor (maker or drawer) has defenses under contract law
Non-negotiable instruments are just regular contracts
Elements of Negotiability
A. In writing.
B. Signed by maker or drawer. Any symbol intended to authenticate will do.
C. Unconditional promise or order to pay (IOU not enough)
D. Fixed Amount. Must be able to look at instrument and determine principal amount do.
E. In Money. (Words v. Figures = Words prevail)
F. No other undertaking or instruction
G. Payable on demand or at a definite time
H. Contains words of negotiability
Items that DO NOT make a promise or order conditional
a. Statement of consideration
b. Reference to another record that is not conditioned on that record (e.g., “as per” or “in accordance with”
c. Incorporation by reference of items that would not hurt holder
1 Rights regarding collateral
2. Prepayment
3. Acceleration
d. Limitation of payment to a particular fund or source
e. Countersignature
f. Consumer protection language (but this will prevent holder from being a holder in due course
Negotiability Elements: Unconditional Promise or Order to Pay
Negotiability Elements: No Other Undertaking or Instruction
Exceptions: Promises concerning collateral and waiver of law meant to benefit the obligor
Negotiability Elements: Payable on Demand or at a Definite Time
On Demand - A note is payable on demand if an express statement is used providing for payment “on demand” or “at sight” or if the instrument does not state the date it is due
At a Definite Time - Can be on a specified date, a fixed period after sight or acceptance, or at a time readily ascertainable at the time the promise or order is issued
These do not prevent instrument form being payable oat a definite time:
a. Prepayment of Instrument (right of obligor to pay early)
b. Acceleration of Due Date
c. Provisions Extending the Due Date
- -By holder = to any time
- -By obligor = to a later definite time stated in the instrument
- -Automatically upon condition stated in instrument = to a later definite time stated in the instrument
Negotiability Elements: Words of Negotiability
Negotiation: Holder Status
Achieved when the payee transfers the instrument to a third party rather than just getting the money.
Requirements:
Blank Indorsements***
Created with payee’s signature on a negotiable instrument.
Effect: Creates bearer paper. Further negotiations achieved by possession only