Ethics Structure

Question 1

Introduction

Answer 1

Argument: comm bad, migration controls can’t be justified

1. Comm argument - Walzer
2. Cospmopolitan Arguments - classic lib scholars and open boarders
3. policy implications of these ethics
4. reparations and colonial justice

Question 2

Argument #1

Answer 2

Communitarian arguments

1) Walzer Arguments
2) Membership Arguments
3) Mutual Aid Limitations
4) Aristotle
5) Criticisms of Communitarianism

Question 3

Argument #2:

Answer 3

Cosmopolitanism arguments

1) Nozick
2) Rawls
3) Risse
4) Bentham/ Utilitarianism
5) Liberal Case for Open Boarders
6) Precarity, Bare Life

Question 4

Argument #3:

Answer 4

Policy Implications of Ethics

1. Carens - ideal vs real
2. Liberal Paradox - Hollified
3. ‘Minimum Standards’

Question 5

Argument #4:

Answer 5

Colonial Reparations

1. what responsibility do states have to right colonial wrongs
2. who is the subject with rights and who is simply the producer of labour
3. African scholars