Gender differences in general intelligence - tests
-Terman-> Stanford Binet Test found No difference
- Spearman -> girls slightly higher then boys on g
- Cattell -> fluid + crystalised intelligence No difference
-Makintesh ->Raven’s matrices no difference
- Anderson -> WAIS No difference
Gender differences at different ages
specific Intelligences
-Maccoby + Jacklin
-men perform better on spatial
ability (small to medium effect size)
-women perform better on verbal ability (very small effect size)
Gender Difference is closing
Nature Debate-Brain Size
-Males brains are 10% larger but only after adolescence
-girls brain mature faster in adolescence
-Pietsching et al: link is small + overused
Nature Debate- Brain structure -hemispheres
Nature Debate-Brain function
-males use right hemisphere when completing mental rotation task, females use both = less efficient (slower)
-Haier et al :
> women with higher IQ have more white Matter vol (info transfer) Men have more grey matter (info processing)
> grey Matter volume correlates with intelligence
Nature Debate-Hormones
-Hooven et al :
> testosterone level neg correlated with error rate + response time in Male college students
- Choi + Silverman : > women use relative directions + landmarks to learn routes whereas men Use distance + cardinal directions
> among men testesterone level is pos related to using male-biased route learning strategies
Nature Debate- Evolutionary
-Males need spatial ability: hunting large areas, warfare + Max reproductive success
-Jones et al: Males with greater spatial ability more likely to win wars, supply food, More attractive
Social env impacts spatial ability -tribe study
-Hoffman et al
-spatial Ability in 2 genetically related tribes
-overall females take longer
-patrilineal (father passes things down to son) tribe has bigger male VS femAle performance difference
-matriliniel have no difference
-suggests social env ( organisation) impacts spatial ability
Nurture debate -3 stereotypes origin
-Reinforcement (Langlois + Down): parents reinforce sex appropriAte + discourage sex inappropriate beh
- Modelling: children observe same sex models + gain stereotypes= gender identity
-socialisation of boys (Entwistle et al): boys given freedom to explore =spatial ability
Nurture Debate: stereotypes in education
-subject choice:
> females less likely to choose STEM as stereotyped as masc So less likely to dev spatial skills
talented children encouraged to dev skills - > increases self-esteem -> study more
-Moss-Racusin et al: apply for lab manager in STEM identical application given Male or female name rate men as more competent + hierable
-Interactins - self-fulfilling Prophecy:
> stereotype threat = stereotype makes performance worse due to fear
- Spencer et al:
Nurture Debate - stereotypes out of ed
-Toy choice :
> boys play with toys encouraging spatial skills
> Campbell et al toy preference in Children as young as 9 months
> Sidorowics + Lunney: adults chose toy Assoc with stereotypical view to play with child
> Alexander + Hines- monkeys show similar sex differences in toy choice to humans
Nature + Nurture: Measurement of inteIligence -mental rotation task
Emotional intelligence
-females have better socio- emotional abilities:
> emotion recognition
> empathy
> emotional intelligence
Technology influences spatial intelligence
-kirby + Boulter: 1 factor predicting success at visual stimuli task (technology) was spatial ability before task, weak spatial ability disadvantaged by complex visual stimuli used as teaching method
socioeconomic status influences spatial skills in classroom
-Levine et al:
- Boys from middle + high socioeconomic status do better than girls on spatial tasks
- low socioeconomic status group didn’t differ in performance because engage less with activities promoting spatial intelligence: using computes, being out in neighborhood