What is the impact of stereotypes and attitudes on communication with older people?
Stereotypes (cognitive representations) and attitudes (emotional responses) create predetermined ideas of how to communicate with older people, which can affect intergenerational interactions.
What is an intergenerational conversation?
A conversation between two or more people of different ages. These conversations can be complex due to diverse approaches, ideas, and expectations (schemas) of communication.
Schema 1 – Overwhelmingly positive interaction
Younger person shows mild restraint/politeness
Mutual warmth and caring
Older person described positively (friendly, loving, caring)
Younger person learns from older
Schema 2 – Positive and helping
Similar to #1, but younger person wants to help the older person (e.g., keep company)
Schema 3 – Positive and respectful
Younger person displays high restraint/politeness
Difficult to find common ground; feels forced to be polite
Older person described positively
Schema 4 – Neutral and distant
Mixed feelings by younger person
Feels forced to be polite but may want to leave or feel bored
Schema 5 – Sympathy and helping
Neutral evaluation of older person (e.g., ill, lonely)
Younger person feels sympathy and wants to help but feels restrained
Schema 6 – No connection
Younger person has negative feelings
Older person described negatively (hostile)
Younger person wants to help but does not enjoy conversation
Schema 7 – No connection and helping
Younger person feels no connection, negative feelings
Feels bored but still wants to help older person
Schema 8 – Negative and hostile
Older person is hostile, angry, and displays negative attitudes
Younger person wants to leave conversation
What does the Communication Accommodation Theory (CAT) explain?
CAT explains how people consciously or unconsciously adjusts their communication style—such as speech, voice, gestures, and vocabulary—depending on who they are talking to, in order to accommodate others.
What does CAT suggest about intergenerational communication?
CAT helps explain why communication between different age groups can be effective or problematic, depending on whether the adjustments made are appropriate or inappropriate.
What are the two major forms of inappropriate accommodation in CAT?
Over-accommodation – adjusting too much.
Under-accommodation – not adjusting enough.
What is over-accommodation in CAT?
Over-accommodation occurs when a speaker goes too far in adjusting to the communication partner’s perceived needs, usually based on stereotypes rather than actual needs (e.g., speaking to an older adult as if they were a child).
What are characteristics of patronising talk/elderspeak (over-accommodation)
Slower rate
Exaggerated intonation
Elevated pitch and volume
Greater repetition
Use of diminutives and collective pronouns
Endearing terms (e.g., sweetie, love)
Simplified vocabulary and grammar (baby talk)
What is under-accommodation in CAT?
Under-accommodation occurs when a speaker fails to adjust their communication enough to meet the other person’s needs or cues.
Why is under-accommodation considered inappropriate?
It violates conversational norms by sharing overly intimate information or using communication styles (e.g., slang or jargon) that the other person doesn’t understand.
What phenomenon does the communication predicament of Ageing (CPA) model build on?
The over-accommodation phenomenon from CAT.
What does the CPA model explain?
The CPA model explains how age-related cues (e.g., grey hair, wrinkles) trigger stereotyping by younger speakers, leading to over-accommodative behaviour.
What are the consequences of over-accommodation in the CPA model?
Restricts the older adult’s participation in conversation.
Reduces self-efficacy, self-esteem, and social image.
Reinforces the negative stereotypes that caused the behaviour.
How does the CPA create a cycle of negative communication?
Encounter with older person → Recognition of age cues and activation of stereotypes → Modified (patronising) communication → Reduced communication opportunities →
Loss of control, self-esteem, and social interaction → Physiological, psychological, and sociocultural decline → (back to encounter)
How does the Communication Enhancement Model differ from the CPA model?
CPA focuses on negative consequences of stereotyping and over-accommodation.
CEM focuses on positive, individualised communication that enhances interaction and quality of life.
What does the Communication Enhancement Model emphasise?
Recognising an older adult’s individual characteristics and tailoring communication strategies to their specific needs and abilities.
What are examples of appropriate communication adjustments under the CEM?
Speaking clearly to a client with hearing impairment.
Using visual cues or repetition to enhance understanding.
Avoiding unnecessary simplification or elderspeak if not needed.