What is a fee simple absolute?
The largest estate; it is capable of lasting forever. Inheritable: Upon the owner’s death, the owner can pass it by will or by intestate succession; can also be transferred by gift or sale during owner’s life. To create: Look for magic words ‘and his/her heirs’ — but these are not required; ‘O to A’ or ‘O to A and her heirs’ are the same thing. Fee simple absolute is the default estate; there’s a presumption that the grantor conveys the most that it has. Don’t be fooled by words of intent or purpose.
This estate is the most complete form of ownership in real property.
What is a defeasible fee?
May be terminated by the occurrence of an event; capable of lasting forever but also of being terminated early. Condition will cut short the fee simple.
Defeasible fees are subject to specific conditions that can limit their duration.
What is a Fee Simple Determinable?
Limited by specific durational language. Examples: ‘while,’ ‘during,’ ‘until it is no longer used as a farm.’ The fee simple lasts while the period is in play (e.g., while used as a farm), but as soon as the period ends (e.g., when the land is no longer used as a farm), the fee simple ends.
This type of fee automatically reverts to the grantor when the specified condition is no longer met.
What is a Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent?
Limited by specific conditional language. Examples: ‘provided that the land is not farmed,’ ‘on the condition that the land is not farmed.’ Focus on the language to the grantor: Suggests that the grantor must exercise a right in order to take possession.
This type of fee does not automatically terminate but gives the grantor the right to reclaim the property.
What future interests are associated with defeasible fees?
These interests determine what happens to the property if the conditions of the defeasible fees are not met.
What is a remainder?
A future interest that follows what present possessory estate? A life estate. A remainder cannot follow a vested fee simple. Why? A future interest following a vested fee simple would have to divest the prior interest (the fee simple) but a remainder does not function that way because it instead waits for the prior interest to end.
Remainders can be vested or contingent based on the conditions set forth.
Can remainders be vested or contingent?
Yes. RAP generally applies only to contingent remainders. Vested Remainder—an interest that is: (1) Given to an ascertained grantee; and (2) Not subject to a condition precedent (i.e., there is no condition that must be satisfied in order for the interest to vest).
The distinction between vested and contingent remainders affects their validity under the Rule Against Perpetuities.
What is a vested remainder subject to open?
Vested remainder in a class gift; full class membership is unknown. At least one person in the class must be vested for it to be vested subject to open; if no one in the class has vested, the remainder is contingent. When all members of a class are identified, the class is closed.
This concept is important for understanding how interests in property can change over time.
What is the Rule of Convenience for class gifts?
A class-closing mechanism to avoid application of the rule against perpetuities. The grant does not have an express closing date, the Rule of Convenience closes the class when any member of the class becomes entitled to immediate possession.
This rule helps to determine when a class gift is considered complete.
What is a reversion?
Future interest held by a grantor following something other than the grantor. The future interest is held by a transferee. Interest vests automatically.
Reversions occur when a grantor conveys an estate but retains a future interest in the property.
What is an executory interest?
Future interest that will cut short or terminate, an earlier interest. Two kinds: * Springing executory interest: Divests the grantor. * Shifting executory interest: Divests a prior grantee.
Executory interests are important for understanding how interests in property can be transferred.
When are interests created in inter vivos transfers?
Inter vivos transfers: Interests created at time of the grant. Devise (will): Interests created at testator’s death, not when the will is drafted.
This distinction is crucial for determining the timing of property interests.
What interests are subject to RAP?
RAP applies to: * contingent remainders; * executory interests; * gifts (subject to open), if not closed by rule of convenience. Does not apply to vested remainders unless subject to open.
The Rule Against Perpetuities limits the duration of certain future interests.
Who is a relevant life?
Relevant life: Person who affects vesting, usually mentioned or implied by the grant (e.g., prior life tenant, the parent where a conveyance is made to a child). Validating life: Person who tells us whether or not the interest vests within the perpetuities period (lifetime plus 21 years). Must have been alive when the interests were created; can validate her own interest; if no validating life, then the interest is no good and we strike it from the grant; if there is a validating life, then the interest is good.
Identifying relevant and validating lives is essential for applying the Rule Against Perpetuities.
What is a life estate?
Present estate that is limited by a life. Whose life? Example: Oliver conveys Blackacre ‘to Anna for life.’ This life estate is measured against Anna’s life. Example: Oliver conveys Blackacre ‘to Anna for Ben’s life.’ Anna’s life estate is measured against ‘pur autre vie’ (meaning measured against the life of someone else).
Life estates are temporary and end when the measuring life dies.
What are the magic words to create a life estate?
‘for life.’ If ambiguous, look for the grantor’s intent to create an estate that will end upon the death of the measuring life.
The intent of the grantor is crucial in determining the nature of the estate.
When does a life estate terminate?
Ends naturally when the measuring life ends. Transferable? Example: Oliver conveys Blackacre ‘to Anna for life.’ Anna later transfers her interest to Ben. When will Ben’s interest terminate? When Anna dies.
Life estates cannot be inherited and end with the death of the measuring life.
Can a life tenant pass the property by will?
No—the life estate ends at the life tenant’s death.
This limitation affects the transferability of interests in property.
What is waste?
Comes into play when more than one party has an interest in the same piece of real property. Example: Oliver conveys Blackacre ‘to Anna for life.’ Anna has been dumping hazardous materials onto the property, which have caused serious damage to Blackacre. The doctrine of waste gives Oliver a claim to stop Anna from injuring the land. Why? Because Oliver has a reversion.
Waste laws protect the interests of property owners from harm caused by tenants.
What are the three kinds of waste?
Understanding the types of waste is essential for property law.
How to spot a waste problem?
Identifying these factors can help in resolving disputes over property interests.
What is the special rule for class gifts under the Rule Against Perpetuities (RAP)?
If a gift to any member of the class is void under RAP, the gift is void as to all members of the class (the ‘all or nothing’ rule)
This rule ensures that if any part of the class gift fails, the entire gift fails.
Under RAP, what presumption applies regarding a person’s ability to have children?
Property law assumes that anyone alive can still have children, regardless of age (fertile octogenarian rule)
This presumption affects the validity of future interests.
What is the ‘unborn widow’ issue under RAP?
A conveyance to someone’s widow may violate RAP if the widow could be unborn at the time of the conveyance, potentially delaying vesting beyond the perpetuities period
This issue highlights the complexities of future interests and potential beneficiaries.