What is self-defence?
General defence using reasonable force; full defence
Where does self-defence come from?
Common law + Criminal Justice & Immigration Act 2008
What are the two key questions in self-defence?
What does ‘necessary force’ mean?
Subjective: what D believed
Which case shows pre-emptive force allowed?
Beckford – threat imminent, can strike first
Key rule from Beckford?
Force allowed if D honestly believes threat
Which case shows genuine mistake can still give defence?
Gladstone Williams
Key rule from Gladstone Williams?
Honest mistake → defence still applies
What happens if mistake is due to intoxication?
No defence
Which case shows intoxicated mistake fails?
O’Grady
Is there a duty to retreat?
No, but jury may consider it
Which case shows no duty to retreat?
R v Bird
What does ‘proportionate force’ mean?
Objective: reasonable in circumstances
Which Act governs proportionality?
Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008
What does s.76(3) state?
Jury judges based on D’s belief of circumstances
What does s.76(7)(a) state?
D not expected to calculate exact force
What does s.76(7)(b) state?
If force necessary (to D), likely reasonable
Which case shows excessive force not allowed?
Hussain
Key rule from Hussain?
Revenge/retaliation ≠ self-defence
What is special rule for householder cases?
Force can be disproportionate but not grossly disproportionate
Which section covers householder defence?
s.76(5A) CJIA 2008
Which case shows householder limit?
R v Martin