culture shapes how we
communicate
core definitions about communication/culture,
1 from Hofstede
2 from Hall
Hofstede: shared mental software about how people think, feel and act.
Hall:
1 - system where everything connects.
2: communication // culture (can’t be seperated)
5 levels of cultures:
1: National culture: differences between countries.
Example: German directness vs. Chinese indirectness.
2: Regional culture: e.g., people in Twente (NL) vs. people from the western Netherlands.
3: Organizational culture: shared norms and values within a company.
4: Subculture: groups within a culture (youth, religion, politics, music scene).
5: Individual differences: education, generation, personality, etc.
Why compares Edward T. Hall culture to an iceberg?
Because only a small part is visible above the surface, while most lies hidden beneath.
Iceberg theory (Hall)
Visible part (10%), what?
Observable behaviors: food, dress, music, language, rituals, manners.
Iceberg theory (Hall)
Hidden part (90%), what?
Values, beliefs, norms, assumptions, expectations, thought patterns.
Interpretation of the Iceberg theory of Hall?
The visible parts are expressions of deeper, invisible cultural values.
To understand a culture, one must dive below the surface.
Example: In Japan, bowing is visible; the deeper meaning is respect and hierarchy. In the Netherlands, speaking directly reflects the deeper value of equality and honesty.
Hofstede’s Onion Model of Culture,
it’s compared with? And why?
Onion with several layers.
The outer layers are easier to see and change; the inner core is deeply rooted.
Hofstede’s Onion Theory
Layers from outside → inside
Interpretation of the Onion theory from Hofstede
Values drive all other cultural expressions. Rituals, heroes, and symbols change faster, but the inner values are stable and resistant to change.
Example: In Dutch work culture, punctuality (a ritual) reflects the value of reliability and structure.
Schwartz’s Theory of Basic Human Values
Shalom Schwartz proposed that human values form a universal structure,
but each culture prioritizes them differently.
Values (definition)
Values are fundamental beliefs that guide behavior and help people decide what is important.
Key value groups (10 total, across two opposing poles):
1.1: Openness to change (vrijheid)
- Self-direction (onafhankelijkheid)
- Stimulation (spanning)
<->
1.2: Conservation (stabiliteit)
- Tradition (traditie)
- Conformity (gehoorzaamheid)
- Security (veiligheid)
2.1: Self-enchancement (persoonlijk succes)
- Hedonism (plezier, genot)
- Achievement (succes)
- Power (status)
2.2: Self-Transcedence (zorg voor anderen)
- Universalism (gelijkheid)
- Benevolence (zorg voor anderen)
Etic and Emic Approaches,
description and pro/con:
etic: Outside perspective – comparing cultures using the same framework.
- pro: easy to compare.
- con: Can be superficial or stereotypical.
emic: Inside perspective – understanding culture through its own logic.
- pro: Deep insight into meanings and behaviors.
- con: Limited comparability; may lack objectivity.
o An etic study might compare “politeness” across countries…
o An emic study would explore what “politeness” means …
etic: using one scale.
emic: in Japan vs. the Netherlands.
Static vs. Dynamic Views of Culture
(perspectives)
Static perspective: Treats culture as stable and measurable → focuses on differences between cultures.
Example: “Dutch people are direct, Chinese are indirect.”
Dynamic perspective:
Recognizes culture as constantly evolving → focuses on diversity within cultures and changes over time.
Example: Younger Chinese professionals may value individual achievement more than older generations.
Ocean metaphor (Fang):
Culture is like the…
The sea is always… >
Culture is like the ocean: visible waves = behavior, but the deep currents = enduring values.
The sea is always moving
→ culture is never fixed.
Organizations also develop their own
mini-cultures
Schein’s Model of Organizational Culture,
3 levels:
Hofstede’s Six Organizational Dimensions (1990)
1) Process vs. Results Orientation
- How things are done vs what is achieved.
2) Employee vs. Job Orientation
- Focus on people vs tasks.
3) Parochial vs. Professional
- Loyalty to company vs loyalty to expertise.
4) Open vs. Closed System
- Welcoming vs secretive culture.
5) Loose vs. Tight Control
- Flexible vs strict rule-following.
6) Normative vs. Pragmatic
- Doing what’s “right” vs doing what “works.”
Emotional Intelligence
The ability to perceive, understand, expres and regulate emotions to promote emotional and intellectual growth.
Perspective-taking
Seeing a situation from another person’s point of view
what is another synoniem of ‘perspective-taking’
the cognitive side of empathy
Perspective-taking is essential for what type of communication?
intercultural communication:
- Example: When a Dutch designer creates a manual for Chinese readers, they must imagine how the message feels to the other culture.