Land Law - Leases
When may equity intervene to recognise an equitable lease?
What is required for equity to recognise the arrangement?
A contract, complying with s2 LPMPA 1989, and clean hands.
Land Law - Leases
When is a deed required to create a lease?
Required to create a legal lease unless a parol lease.
Land Law - Leases
What equitable right will be created by a contract to transfer an existing legal estate?
An estate contract.
Land Law - Leases
What are the essential characteristics of a lease?
What has been created where 1 or more of the essential characteristics of a lease is missing?
A licence.
Land Law - Leases
How is a licence different from a lease?
Land Law - Leases
What will be created in an attempt to create a lease for life?
A lease for a term of 90 years which ends on the death of the tenant.
Land Law - Leases
What is a break clause?
A contractual right to bring a fixed term lease to a premature end.
Land Law - Leases
What are the features of exclusive possession?
Does the landowner retaining a key negate exclusive possession?
No, it does not.
Land Law - Leases
Does service occupancy create a licence or lease?
A licence.
Land Law - Leases
(Drafting) What are the key lease covenants?
In the absence of an express obligation, which covenants will be implied on the part of the landlord to include?
Tenant’s covenants:
- rent
- contribution to insurance
- repair
- alterations
- alienation
Landlord’s covenants
- quiet enjoyment
- insurance
Implied in the absence of an express obligation:
- quiet enjoyment; and
- obligations in respect of fitness of the property.
Land Law - Leases
What are the landlord’s obligations in respect of fitness of the property?
When will a landlord be liable for obligations in respect of fitness of the property?
Only liable if there is disrepair and once such disrepair has been notified to them.
Land Law - Leases
What is alienation? How may a tenant exercise alienation?
What is assignment?
Alienation - disposal of the existing (and remaining) leasehold estate by the tenant.
- assignment;
- sub-lease;
- mortgage/charge;
- parting with possession/occupation
Assignment - the tenant passes all of their interest under the lease to a new tenant and steps out of the picture.
Land Law - Leases
What does it mean if the lease does not contain a covenant against alienation?
The tenant has complete freedom to deal with the lease as they wish.
Land Law - Leases
Qualified vs Fully Qualified Covenants (Assignment context)?
Qualified - the covenant by the tenant is not to assigned without the landlord’s consent
Fully qualified - covenant not to assign the lease without the landlord’s consent, which cannot be unreasonably withheld
Land Law - Leases
What is the effect of s19 Landlord and Tenant Act (LTA) 1927?
When does it impose obligations on the landlord?
Translates any qualified covenant (against assignment, underletting, charging or parting with possession) into a fully qualified covenant so that the landlord cannot unreasonably withhold consent.
Imposes obligations on the landlord where the landlord has received a written application:
- to give consent (unless reasonable not to do so);
- to give written notice of their decision (including any conditions); and
- where consent is withheld, written reasons for refusal.
Land Law - Leases
What does s19(1A) LTA 1927 enable the original landlord and tenant of a NON-RESIDENTIAL lease (granted after 1 Jan 1996) to agree in advance?
The most popular condition is for the former tenant to provide the landlord with an AGA as a condition of the landlord giving its consent to any assignment.
Land Law - Leases
Old vs New Leases?
Old leases - created before 1 Jan 1996
New leases - created after 1 Jan 1996
Land Law - Leases
What is the liability of the original tenant under an old lease?
Liability of the assignee under an old lease?
Who can the landlord pursue if the assignee defaults? What if a landlord sells to a new landlord?
ORIGINAL TENANT:
There is a relationship if privity of contract between the original tenant and the original landlord.
- T1’s contractual liability lasts for the duration of the lease (even after assignment).
ASSIGNEE:
When the original tenant assigns the lease to an assignee, there is a relationship of privity of estate between the landlord and T2.
- T2 is liable for breaches of all real covenants (those which touch and concern the land (positive and negative)).
- T2 only liable under privity of estate for the duration that the lease is vested in them.
The landlord can pursue T1 (via privity of contract), T2 (via privity of estate) or both of them.
The new landlord can pursue either, as they have the benefits and burdens of the landlord’s covenants whilst the reversion is vested in them.
Land Law - Leases
OLD LEASE - if the original tenant is sued as a result of a breach they did not commit, what action can they take?
Land Law - Leases
What is the position of the tenants under a new lease? Original and assignee?
What is the position of the original landlord? The new landlord, upon sale of the reversion?
How can an outgoing landlord be released?
Who can a tenant pursue?
Tenants are only bound by the covenants in the lease whilst the lease is vested in them. On assignment, all the covenants pass to the assignee unless expressed to be personal (does not matter if they touch and concern the land) AND the assigning tenant is automatically released from any liability.
The new landlord takes the burden and benefit of the covenants, provided not expressed to be personal (do not need to touch and concern the land).
The outgoing landlord is not automatically released.
Must follow the criteria in ss6 and 8 LT(C)A to be released from landlord covenants. Alternatively, landlord can limit their liability by stating in the lease that their liability ends once they have disposed of the reversion.
If former landlord not released, the tenant can pursue either the former landlord, new landlord, or both.
Land Law - Leases
What is the position of the landlord under a new lease?
When is the outgoing landlord released following an assignment of the reversion?
What happens if not released? Effect?
How can a landlord limit their liability?
The new landlord takes the burden of the landlord covenants and acquires the benefit of tenant covenants (they do not need to touch and concern the land).
The outgoing landlord is not automatically released following an assignment of the reversion.
Has to follow the criteria in ss6 and 8 LT(C)A 1995 to obtain a release from the landlord covenants.
If release is not obtained, the outgoing landlord remains liable on the landlord covenants. Means the tenant will have a choice of pursuing the former landlord, new landlord or both.
Can limit their liability by stating in the lease that their liability ends once they have disposed of the reversion.
Land Law - Leases
When can a landlord require an AGA?
Only where:
- the lease contains a covenant against alienation without the landlord’s consent; and
- it is either reasonable to do so or, in the case of a commercial lease, it is a condition of the landlord giving consent.
Land Law - Leases
A former tenant who suffers loss due to liability under an AGA as a consequence of the default of an assignee may recover how?
Are indemnity covenants implied on every assignment of new leases?
Unlike old leases, indemnity covenants are not implied on every assignment.
Land Law - Leases
What must the landlord do before pursuing a former tenant for the payment of rent?
What happens if they don’t?
What happens if the former tenant pays in full?
Does this apply to new and old leases?
They must serve a default notice on the former tenant within 6 calendar months of the fixed charge falling due.
If the landlord fails to serve a default notice, they cannot recover the fixed charge from the former tenant.
If the former tenant pays the sum demanded in full, the former tenant can request an overriding lease from the landlord.
Applies to both new and old leases.