effective spread for buy order =
2x ( execution - midquote)
effective spread for sell order =
2x ( midquote - execution )
as the traders agent, brokers do:
liquid market has:
execution costs :
explicit and implicit
explicit execution costs
commissions
taxes
stamp duties
fees
implicit execution costs
bid ask spread
market or price impact costs
opportunity costs
delay costs (slippage)
components of implementation shortfall
explicit costs
realized profit loss
delay or slippage cost
missed trade opportunity cost
implementation shortfall – realized profit/loss =
(exe - previous close) / decision * purchased / ordered
implementation shortfall – delay or slippage cost =
( previous close - decision ) / decision * purchased / ordered
implementation shortfall – missed opportunity
( cancelation - decision ) / decision * cancelled / ordered
implementation shortfall (paper) =
( paper portfolio gain - real portfolio gain ) / paper portfolio investment
advantages of volume weighted average price
disadv of volume weighted average price
advantages of implementation shortfall
disadv of implementation shortfall
may not be familiar to traders
requires considerable data and analysis
information motivated traders (motivation, needs, order)
possess time senzitive information
need quick execution
place market orderss
value motivated traders (motivation, needs, order)
security misvaluation
need good price
place limit order
liquidity motivated traders (motivation, needs, order)
reallocation and liquidity
need quick execution
place market orders
passive traders (motivation, needs, order)
reallocation and liquidity
need good price
place limit orders
trading tactics
liquidity at any cost costs are not important need trustworthy agent advertise to draw liquidity low cost whatever the liquidity
liquidity at any cost - trading tactics (+, -, motivation)
+quick certain execution
- high costs and leakage of info
motivation : information
costs are not important - trading tactics (+, -, motivation)
+quick certain execution
- loss of control of trade costs
motivations : diverse
need trustworthy agent - trading tactics (+, -, motivation)
+brokers use skill and time to obtain good price
- high commission and potential leakage
motivation : not information