Steps in formulation of capital market expectations
DETERMINE the specific capital market EXPECTATIONS NEEDED according to the investor’s tax status, allowable asset classes, and time horizon.
INVESTIGATE assets’ HISTORICAL PERFORMANCE to determine the drivers.
IDENTIFY the VALUATION MODEL used and its requirements.
COLLECT the BEST DATA possible.
Use experience and judgment to INTERPRET CURRENT MARKET CONDITIONS and decide what values to assign to the required inputs.
FORMULATE CAPITAL MARKET EXPECTATIONS.
MONITOR performance and use it to REFINE the process.
Factors in evaluation of data
Calculation methodologies. Data collection techniques. Data definitions. Error rates. Investability and correction for free float. Turnover in index components. Potential biases.
Nine problems encountered in producing forecasts
EE LL MM NN P
(2) Error and bias in data measurement,
(4) Ex post risk and return measures being used,
(1) Limitations to using economic data,
(3) Limitations of historical estimates,
(7) Misinterpretation of correlations,
(9) Model and input uncertainty.
(5) Non-repeating data patterns,
(6) Not accounting for conditioning information,
(8) psychological traps, and
data measurement errors and biases
transcription errors (recording)
survivorship bias
appraisal (smoothed) data
Benefits from using long term data
. It may be statistically required.
. provides more precise statistical estimates
. less sensitive to the starting and ending points selected for the time period.
Problems from using long term data
. Regime changes
. relevant time period is too short to be statistically significant
. more frequent data points are often more likely to have missing or outdated values (asynchronism) and can result in lower, distorted correlation calculations.
Gordon growth model or constant growth mode
P0 (current) = D1 (next) /(R-g)
Grinol Kroner model
Ri = exp ( income return) + exp (NOMINAL earnings growth ) + exp ( repricing return)
= ( D1/P0 - stock count growth) + (inflation + growth) + (p/e extension)
Bond returns - risk premium approach
R = real risk-free rate + .......... In de li ma ta \+ inflation risk premium \+ default risk premium \+ liquidity risk premium \+ maturity risk premium \+ tax premium
CAPM model - return =
R=Rfr + asset beta x (market R - Rfr)
Risk premium bonds & stocks =
Standard deviation x correlation x Sharpe
ERP - equity risk premium
ERP =
= Standard deviation
x Correlation with global market (1 if fully segmented)
x Sharpe ratio
+ Illiquidity premium for developing countries
ERP including segmentation / integration =
Degree of segmentation x ERP segmentation +
+ Degree of integration x ERP integration +
Beta =
Correlation A with market x Standdev asset A / Standdev market
The longer-term business cycle - length and phases
9 to 11 years
the initial recovery, early upswing, late upswing, slowdown, recession.
Initial Recovery • • •
Few months.
Rising stocks (esp risk assets), confidence.
Falling inflation, short term interest
Government stimulation: low rates and/or budget deficits.
Large output gap
Bond yields are bottoming out.
Early Upswing • • • • • • • •
1+ years
Increasing growth with low inflation, confidence, inventories, stocks, short term interest, bond yields
Output gap is narrowing.
Late Upswing • • • • • • •
Confidence and employment are high.
Output gap eliminated and economy at risk of overheating.
Central bank limits the growth of the money supply.
Rising inflation, short-term interest rates, bond yields, stock (increased risk and volatility)
Slowdown
Few months - 1yr or longer.
Inflation is still rising.
Falling inventory levels, stocks, confidence.
Peaking Short-term interest rates and Bond yields.
Yield curve may invert.
Recession
Duration of 6mo-1yr.
Large declines in inventory.
Declining confidence, profits, short-term interest rates, bond yields, rising bond prices
Increase in unemployment and bankruptcies.
Inflation tops out.
Stock prices increase during the latter stages anticipating the end of the recession.
Taylor rule
Rtarget = Rneutral + 0.5(GDPexpected-GDPtrend + InflationExpected-InflationTrend)
If Monetary and Fiscal are stimulative, the yield curve is
steep and the economy is likely to grow.
If monetary and fical are restrictive, the yield curve is
inverted and the economy is likely to contract.
If monetary is restrictive and fiscal is stimulative, the yield curve is
flat and the economy is unclear.