what do we need to do to remember information?
consciously encode information
what was Simon & Emmons (1956) study?
during sleep, participants hear questions and answers every five minutes
participants’ EEG recorded throughout the night to monitor their sleep
subsequently asked questions they heard overnight
scores divided by EEG sleep state at time the question and answer were played
what were the results of Simons & Emmons (1956) study?
overall - performance above chance, learning had occurred
awake but relaxed - 80% learned
drowsy - 50% learned
drowsiness/light sleep transition - 5% learned
asleep - no effect
what was Bruce, Evans, Fenwick & Spencer’s (1970) study?
present material to sleeping subjects then awaken them immediately
no evidence for memory
what doesn’t the absence of learning about external events while asleep imply?
we can’t remember internal events such as dreams
sleep doesn’t play important role in consolidation of memories
what was Levinson’s (1965) study?
memory during anaesthesia
10 dental surgery patients experience mock crisis during surgery
one month later patients were hypnotised
what were the results of Levinson’s (1965) study?
four patients produced almost verbatim reports of the anaesthetist’s comments
4 produced partial reports
only 2 produced no recall at all under hypnosis
what were the major problems of Levinson’s (1965) study?
serious ethical questions
no control condition
suggestibility under hypnosis
experimenter not blind to hypothesis/condition - Levinson was hypnotist
no measure of degree of anaesthesia
what are the two issues the phenomenon Levinson (1965) raises?
anaesthesia may not be total (“cocktail issue”) - anaesthetic (hypnotic agent), analgesic (removes pain), muscle relaxant (allows surgery), amnesia agent (prevents memory?)
different tests of memory may reveal different evidence for memory from anaesthesia
what is explicit memory?
requires conscious recollection of prior experiences
what is implicit memory?
knowledge revealed by tasks that don’t require reference to a specific memory episode
what are typical explicit memory tasks?
free recall
cued recall
recognition
what is free recall?
participant attempts to remember target information without any assistance from the experimenter
what is cued recall?
remember specific items based on some specific cue
participants attempts to remember the target information in the presence of some specific cue (e.g. associate of the word they’re trying to remember)
what is recognition?
participant presented with a stimulus and must decide whether it’s the one they were asked to remember
what are typical implicit memory tests?
word stem completion
word fragment completion
degraded picture naming
when are participants better at implicit memory tasks?
if have recently encountered the correct/full item (priming)
but don’t need to be consciously aware of encounter at time of testing
what was Iselin-Chaves et al (2005) study?
implicit memory under anaesthesia
depth of anaesthesia carefully monitored using EEG bispectral index - BIS ranges from 100 (awake) to 0 (minimal brain activity)
participants listen to two lists of 20 words, each presented 25 times
one word presented each 4 seconds - 70 minutes of presentation
words are all 6 letters long and each word shares a stem (first 3 letters) with at least 4 other (French) words
implicit memory tested by word stem completion
what is Jacoby’s (1991) process dissociation procedure?
inclusion test - produce items from any source
exclusion test - only produce items that you didn’t study
R = conscious recollection
A = unconscious/automatic memory
inclusion = R + A(1-R)
exclusion = A(1-R)
R = inclusion - exclusion
A = exclusion / (1-R)
what were Iselin-Chaves et al’s (2005) results?
as anaesthesia gets less deep, degree of automatic influence increases significantly
when anaesthesia is relatively light and testing is implicit, can get some information encoded during anaesthesia
how good is memory for common objects?
often surprisingly poor
who investigated weapon focus?
Loftus (1979)
Loftus, Loftus & Messo (1987)
what is weapon focus?
stress (during a crime) causes attention focusing such that only “central information” is attended to (e.g. attacker’s knife rather than face)
how can weapon focus be experimentally demonstrated?
change in attention (measured using eye-tracking) in stressful situations is relatively easy to demonstrate
memory changes can be more subtle