Feldblum Paper on Surplus
Covers:
1) Surplus
2) Non Admitted Assets
3) Liabilities (PDR)
4) Double Taxation
Feldblum Topics
GOAL: determine the capital supporting the insurance policy by:
1) traces the computation of statutory surplus
2) traces differences from GAAP equity
3) contrasts statutory surplus (and GAAP equity) with invested capital
4) adds the capital in the policyholder reserves with the capital required by statutory regulations
return on capital models
Replaced investment income offset
Used for pricing and performance measurement.
The pricing models vary in their definitions of capital,
Importance:
1) Valuation results differ sharply
2) proper valuation relies on an accurate assessment of the capital supporting insurance operations
Simple investment income offset -
Robbin, ‘The Underwriting Profit Provision” [1992], algorithms 1 and 2.
Older, simple Model that reduced the underwriting profit margin for the investment income earned on policyholder supplied funds
Con: did not consider capital or surplus
Surplus Deviation
(testable)
2 Approaches
Balance Sheet
Income Statement
Both are statutory methods of calculating surplus since GAAP does not exclude non-admitted assets
Balance Sheet Definition of Surplus
Surplus = Assets - Liabilities
Balance Sheet Definition: Statutory
Statutory accounting is on an accrual basis, not a cash basis
makes no difference whether the premium has been collected or is still owed the company (so long as the receivable is admitted)
no difference whether the losses are paid or held as reserves
Income Statement Definition of Surplus
Surplus = Prior Surplus + Income
Original surplus at start of year and add income
Income Statement Definition of Surplus
Revenue: premium earned
Expenditures: losses incurred
and underwriting expenses
Net income = revenues minus expenditures = addition to surplus during the year
Balance Sheet Approach:
Beginning surplus : 2000
Cash: 2000
Written Prem: 1000
Expense Inc: 250
Loss Inc: 600
End of Yr Paid Loss: 200
Assets:
+ Cash 2000
+1000 WP
- Expense 250
- Case reserves(600 Inc - 400 Pd)
Liab:
400 Case
12/31 Surplus: 2000+2000-250 - (600-200) - 400 = 2150
Income Statements Approach:
Beginning surplus : 2000
Cash: 2000
Written Prem: 1000
Expense Inc: 250
Loss Inc: 600
End of Yr Paid Loss: 200
Beginning Surplus: 2000
Income:
1000 - 250 - 600
Ending Surplus = 2150
Adjustment to surplus - Non-Admitted Assets
Balance sheet approach: Removes the Non admitted from the asset
Income Statement approach: Adjust the income by the direct change in surplus (aka decrease income by the non admitted asset)
Examples of Adjustments to Surplus
1) change in non-admitted assets
2) change in the provision for reinsurance
3) direct charges or credits to surplus
Differences in BS and IS approach:
Surplus
some balance sheet transactions do not flow through the income statement
Differences in BS and IS approach:
Non Admitted Assets
the income statement does not differentiate between admitted and non-admitted assets
it is not affected by statutory liabilities so you must adjust the net income with Charges to Direct Surplus (+/- non-admitted assets)
NON-ADMITTED ASSETS
The balance sheet recognizes only the admitted portion of assets
balance sheet calculation of policyholders’ surplus
Cash on hand or on deposit is another name for surplus
THE ASSET EXHIBIT
To reconcile income statement surplus with balance sheet surplus, we adjust income statement surplus for transactions and statutory accounts that do not flowthrough the income statement.
BS = IS + income surplus + statutory accounts
Exhibit 1, “Analysis of Non-Admitted Assets and Related Items” (page 13 of the
Annual Statement)
change in nonadmitted assets during the year, which is the needed adjustment to the income statement surplus
Why do we want the change in non-admitted assets instead of the non-admitted asset itself?
And why does an increase in non-admitted assets lead to a decrease in surplus?
Think of the total asset as a fixed amount, so an increase in the non-admitted
portion is a decrease in the admitted portion
The income statement shows revenues, which correspond to the increase in total assets. Subtracting the increase in non-admitted assets gives the increase in admitted assets. The increase in non-admitted assets is a direct charge to policyholders’ surplus
THE STATUTORY BALANCE SHEET
The statutory balance sheet uses four columns to reconcile with the income statement:
( 4 ) + ( 3 )
THE STATUTORY BALANCE SHEET: change in the non- admitted asset appears in Exhibit 1 , Analysis of Non-Admitted Assets and Related Items
A positive entry in column 3 means a decrease in non-admitted assets, and a negative entry in column 3 means an increase in non-admitted assets
SURPLUS ADJUSTMENTS
Negative Adjustments to Surplus:
1) increase in non-admitted assets - negative entry in column 3 of Exhibit 1 is carried to page 4 and reduces surplus