what is offender profiling
an investigative tool used to solve crimes. The core assumption of profiling is that criminals operate in a way that reflects their personality, so there’s consistency in crime and their MO
What is MO
how criminals commit crime
what is the top down approach
originates in FBI and involves analysis of previous crime to create a profile of an likely offender. A profiler will then use this knowledge to narrow the field of suspects and it relies on intuition and beliefs of the profiler.
what are the 4 stages in the top down approach
what is data assimilation
information is collected from many sources like DNA, Belongings. An attempt is made to identify the psychological signature of the individual offender
what is a psychological signature
distinct behaviour/actions/fantasies of an offender
what is crime scene classification/ typology
crime scenes are either classed as organised or disorganised. This can then tell if there’s is a distinction between offences and offenders.
what is organised crime
pre-planned, don’t leave much evidence, intelligent, target victims, may live further away,social and sexual competency
what is disorganised crime
spur of the moment, get caught for crimes, crimes of passion, impulsive, lives close to crime, history of sexula/ relationship dysfunction
what is crime reconstruction
hypotheses are generated about the crime sequence of events and the victim’s behaviour. This is to clarify the offender’s MO and if it may link to another crime
what is profile generation
A profile is then developed which includes the offender’ physical characteristics, behavioural habits and demography. This description is used to work out a strategy for the investigation to help catch the offender.
what is demography
ethnicity, social class, job etc
what is a positive evaluation of the top-down approach
(P)- has been successful used to create a profile for offenders
(E)- Arthur Shawcross case and the profile was very accurate- married, white male, low paid job, lived near the river
(L)- strength because using typologies profiling is effective and we can ensure that the criminals are punished accordingly
(H)- devised based on 36 manipulative individuals - likely to not be a good reliable source of information - sample not large, not standardised therefore lacks internal validity- cannot fit everyone
Another strength of the top down approach
(P)- lots of evidence to suggest that top-down appraoch is useful
(E)- Pinzotto (1984)found that profiling assistance was helpful in some way 83% of the time
Brewster-TD profiling helped with the interogation of suspects 62%
Mekta- 85% rise in solved case across 3 states
(L)- provided investigators with a different perspective, new lines of enquiry and may prevent wrongful convictions
H)- approach is based on hunches rather than reasoning- weakness because it reduces the credibility- no reaserch to say why it works- influneced by emotions and memories
weakness of TD approach
P)- difficult to make a distinction between typologies
E)- Turvey- organised/disorganised distinction is false and more likely to be a continum than 2 distinction categories. Offenders can be both categories
L)- weakness because categories may be regarded as generalisation and may not be useful
Furthermore- Canter analysed 39 aspects of serial killing in 100 us murders using small space analysis- no distinction between organised and disorganised - inaccurate and not very useful.
what is the bottom up approach
David Canter-builds a picture of the criminal from facts collected from previous crimes of the same type, therefore no intuition is needed. It’s data driven approach that involves using data from crimes scenes and victims to build a statistical database
what are the 4 psychological principles in this approach BT
interpersonal coherence
time and place
criminal charactersitics
forensics awareness
what is interpersonal coherence
the way they interact with their victims- assumption that their behaviour is consistent across situations and everyday behaviour is similar to the way a crime is committed
what is time and place
time and location gives gives as to where the perpretator lives or works and their mode of travel
what is criminal characteristics
involves putting perpetrator in categories
what is forensic awareness
certain behaviour may reveal knowledge of police techniques, possibly by previously committing a crime and going through the criminal crime justice
what happens after these 4
psychologists work on a profile using statistical techniques like small space analysis
what is small space analysis
A British method of profiling that uses techniques to plot the relationship between crime characteristics on a 2-D map. The data from many crime scenes and offender charcateristics are correlated so the most common connections can be identified
what are the characteristics of small space analysis
-crime characteristics occur together are physically closer
-common characteristics are at the centre
-uncommon characteristics are on the outside