What is a collateral warranty ?
A contractual relationship between a party of the main contract and an external third party. This relationship would not otherwise exist due to privity of contract
Provide an example of when a collateral warranty may be used ?
Between an employer and a subcontractor for if the main con goes insolvent, the employer still has contractual agreements with the sub contractors to fulfill their obligations
What are the common clauses in a collateral warranty ?
The collateral warranty should mirror the main contract agreement. Common terms include limitation of liability, requirements for PI insurance, Novation and assignment rights
What are the standard forms of collateral warranties?
JCT standard form of collateral warranty for a funder
JCT standard from of collateral warranty for a future purchaser or tenant
Sub contractor warranty
Are you aware of any case law associated with collateral warranties ?
Abbey Healthcare v Simply Construct 2024 that established collateral warranties are not construction contracts under the act as their purpose is not to carry out construction works
What are third-party rights ?
Allows third parties to enforce terms of a contract that they are not a party to but which may benefit them in some way.
What legislation governs third party rights?
Contracts (rights of third parties) Act 1999
What are some advantages of third party rights ?
No separate documentation so no associated time and cost implications, unlike collateral warranties
They can be extended to sub contractors, avoiding the need to chase multiple warranties
They provide a level of certainty as once the rights have been negotiated and agreed, there is limited room to revisit the wording
What are some disadvantages of third party rights ?
Lack of flexibility - limited room for negotiation once the rights had been agreed
Require careful drafting to ensure all necessary rights are conferred on the third party e.g the right to commence adjudication
What is assignment ?
Transfers the benefits of the contract to a third party, but the burden remains with the original party to the contract
What are the typical clauses of assignment ?
It is standard to allow assignment of rights twice without consent
The assignment should be notified in writing to the other party
What is novation ?
New contract to transfer the rights and obligations of one contractural party to a new third party
What is an example of novation?
Employers designer may be novated to work with the contractors design team under design and build contract
How does novation affect the employers rights?
They lose all contractual relationships with the novated party and therefore the right to take action for a breach.
A collateral warranty may be drawn between the employer and the novated party
What are the advantages of novation ?
By the employers designer being novated to the contractors design team, they can provide an insightful understanding of the employers expectations and requirements
What are the disadvantages of novation?
A collateral warranty may have to be drawn, which can take time, so that the novated party still have a contractual relationship with the employer in case of breach
What is a Pre Construction Services Agreement?
A contract between the employer and the contractor for pre construction services. The contractor is to perform these services prior to signing the building contract
When would you use a PCSA?
During a two stage tender to facilitate early contractor engagement
What activities can a PCSA be used for ?
Contributing to the design process
Advising on buildability, sequencing and construction risk
Assist with any planning application matters
Advise on selection of specialist contractors
What should be considered when drafting a PCSA?
That the arrangements do not commit the employer to entering into contract with the contractor. The employer should have means of securing another bid if the second stage negotiations fail.
The scope of service is clearly defined and unambiguous for the contractor
What happens at practical completion?
The works are substantially complete with minor defects
Half of the retention is released to the employer
Employer surrenders the rights to apply liquidated damages
Employer is responsible for insuring the building works
Employer is able to gain beneficial occupancy of the development
What is sectional completion?
The completion and handover of works is agreed in stages. It is a contractractual obligation to hand back the section
What is partial possession?
Employer requests to take possession of part of the works from the contractor and the contractor has to give consent.
What is a non- completion certificate ?
The architect issues this certificate to certify the works have not been complete by the relevant completion date. The employer then has the right to withhold liquidated damages as long so the withholding notice has been given.