What can group comparisons give evidence on?
general disease causes or treatment effectiveness
Limitation of group comparison
often fail to address the specific needs of individual patients
Single subject designs
research methodologies that apply experimental principles to study the effects of interventions on a single individual
What do single subject designs allow?
health professionals to apply research principles to their everyday practice
Practical benefit of single subject designs
helps practitioners tailor treatments based on the individual’s response, leading to personalized care
What are single subject designs similar to
quasi-experimental designs
How are single subject designs similar to quasi-experimental designs
they have control over the introduction of the treatment and the timing of the intervention
3 different types of n=1 designs
AB
ABAB
Multiple-baseline designs
What is the nature of study in a Single Subject Design vs. a Case Report
n=1: experimental (manipulates variables)
case report: descriptive (no experimental manipulation)
What is the purpose of a Single Subject Design vs. a Case Report
n=1: to test cause and effect of an intervention on an individual
case report: to describe a unique or unusual case
How is data collected in a Single Subject Design vs. a Case Report
n=1: repeated measurements (before, during, after)
case report: observational
What is the causality of a Single Subject Design vs. a Case Report
n=1: can suggest causality
case report: cannot establish causality
What is the design of a Single Subject Design vs. a Case Report
n=1: systematic, involves baseline and intervention phases
case report: narrative-based, focuses on description
What is and example of a Single Subject Design vs. a Case Report
n=1: study assessing effects of diet change on blood glucose levels
case report: case report on rare side effect of a medication
What is AB design used to assess
the effect of an intervention by comparing data
collected before (A phase) and after (B phase) the introduction of the treatment
AB design is simple but useful in practice for what?
identifying how an intervention might affect an individual’s health outcome
ABAB design what happens to the intervention?
it is withdrawn and then reintroduced
What does ABAB design allow for?
a stronger control of extraneous variables
What does ABAB design help determine?
whether the intervention is truly responsible for changes in the dependent variable
What is ABAB design also known as?
reversal design
2 possible threats to validity of AB designs
maturation
history
What do ABAB studies have stronger control over?
extraneous variables
The reintroduction of baseline condition in ABAB studies helps to do what?
rule out extraneous variables that could have influenced the outcome during the first intervention
The repetition of the B phase in ABAB designs adds more what?
evidence to support that the treatment is effective