What is the primary ethical duty of a QME?
To remain objective and impartial, providing accurate, evidence-based opinions regardless of who pays or benefits.
Why is impartiality critical for QMEs?
QME opinions drive legal outcomes; bias can invalidate reports and destroy credibility.
Mnemonic for QME duty
FAIR FACTS FIRST.
What is a conflict of interest for QMEs?
Any personal/financial/professional tie that could influence objectivity (e.g., treating relationship, business ties).
What must a QME do if a conflict exists?
Disclose immediately and recuse if impartiality may be compromised.
Can a QME treat the same worker they evaluate?
Generally no — dual roles create conflict.
What is the QME’s duty of confidentiality?
Protect PHI; disclose only with proper authorization or legal mandate.
Mnemonic for confidentiality
HIPAA = Hold Info Private, Ask Authorization.
How does HIPAA apply to QMEs?
Safeguard PHI; share only with authorized entities (insurer, WCAB) as allowed.
When can a QME disclose without consent?
When required by law (subpoena, court order, mandated reporting).
What is ex parte communication?
Contact with one party without the other’s knowledge; generally prohibited.
Why avoid ex parte contact?
It can invalidate the QME report and trigger sanctions.
Mnemonic for ex parte rule
NO SOLO TALK.
What if one side sends undisclosed records?
Disclose, provide to the other party, and document in the report.
QME obligation in testimony?
Be truthful, objective, and stay within medical evidence/expertise.
How should a QME prepare for deposition?
Review the record/report, know your rationale, and keep neutral tone.
What is the duty to the court?
Assist the WCAB with unbiased medical opinions framed in medical probability.
Define misrepresentation in med-legal reporting.
Falsifying/omitting evidence or tailoring opinions to a party.
Consequences of misrepresentation?
Sanctions, decertification, civil liability, possible criminal fraud.
Mnemonic for honesty
FACT OVER FAVOR.
Why document thoroughly?
Defensible notes sustain credibility and withstand cross-examination.
Core contents of a defensible report?
History, exam, records reviewed, objective findings, reasoning, causation, apportionment, MMI/PD.
Handling patient dissatisfaction?
Stay professional; explain QME’s neutral role; don’t advocate.