T/F: [Overall]
* Different theories have provided different views on the influence of
diversity.
True
T/F: [Negative view]
* Social comparison theory has provided a theoretical background that
diversity is negative for organizational performance.
True
T/F: [Negative view] Social identity theory has provided a theoretical background that
diversity is positive for organizational performance.
No. Both social identity theory and social comparison theory were
used to support negative views on the effect of diversity.
Diversity Types for Negative View
Social Comparison and Social Identity
“Negative, but strength matters” view
How obvious: Faultline (Chattopadhyay et al.
2004)
“It depends on strength; but still “negative” view
[“Type matters” view]
o Social network diversity related to creativity (Mannix &
Neale 2005)
* State/emergent: Collective affect, information distribution
state
“It depends on the type” view
[“Perceived (vs. objective) diversity matters” view]
-Employees’ recognition/perception of diversity (McKay et
al. 2007)
* Employee perceived diversity climate (Colquitt et al.
2002)
* Managerial perception of unit diversity related to conflict
and performance (Lount et al. 2015)
* Process differences (De Jong et al. 2012)
Recent studies have found the importance of perceived (vs.
objective) diversity in organizational outcomes.
[“Process matters” view]
Performance depends on…
o How the organization/managers perceive/identify
diversity that exist in organization (latent and
explicit)
o Where to focus
o How to facilitate/mute different types of diversity
“Interactive…” view
Interactive view examples
Gender x Race x Education (Jones & King 2014)
* Trait x State/emergent (Homan 2007)
* Composition (e.g., ratio) x Emergent
(Humphrey & Aime 2014)
* Work x Nonwork (e.g., diversity valuing climate of
the region) (Roberson et al. 2017)
* Diversity x Culture
* Gender issue in Asian countries
* Diversity in collectivistic (vs. individualistic)
countries
“Interactive…” view
- Interaction of multiple dimensions of diversity
differentiates consequences
Benefits of Diversity
-Increased creativity/synergy
* Less likelihood of “groupthink” and other bad decisions
* Increased awareness of broad customer base
* More interesting, engaging and developmental work environment
* Decreased likelihood of legal problems
* Better preparation for increased global business focus
* Increased ability to recruit additional diverse individuals
Disadvantages of Diversity
True or false
[“Negative, but strength matters” view]
* The organizational consequences of diversity at work may depend on
the degree of diversity.
True, “Faultline” concept. How obvious the difference is.
[“Type matters” view]
* The organizational consequences of diversity at work may depend on
the types of diversity.
True, Demographic (e.g., race, language) diversity
vs. cognitive, informational diversity
T/F: Diversity in the information source of members can help problem-
solving.
True
True or false
[“Perceived (vs. objective) diversity matters” view]
* An organization’s performance may be affected by how the managers
perceive and identify diversity that exists in the organization.
True
T/F: [“Perceived (vs. objective) diversity matters” view
diversity is more closely related to organizational outcomes
than perceived diversity is.
False. Recent research highlights the role of perceived (vs. objective)
diversity
True or false
[“Process matters” view]
* Given a set of workforces, different managers can focus on different
dimensions of diversity.
True
True or false
[“Process matters” view]
Different managers may have different approaches about how to
deal with a given diversity.
True or false
[“Process matters” view]
*Categorization Elaboration Model suggests that the process of
identifying and managing diversity can affect work behaviors of
employees.
True
How to manage colorblindness
-Ignoring the differences
- Unrealistic
How to manage Meritocracy
How to manage Assimilation
T/F: Ignoring the differences can be unrealistic in some organizations.
TrueLimitation of colorblindness strategy